The only thing I can truthfully say, without any fluff, is that I love to be thoroughly entertained. Be it with violence, comedy, drama, or romance- it's not the poison you use, but how you use it. Basically, if an anime does something well, and maintains an originality that makes it stand apart, that's the kind of anime I want to watch.
Again, originality is very important to me. The exception to that statement is that I like a good satire or parody.
Oh, and I hardly ever watch dubs. I think the only dubs I truly prefer over the subs is Cromartie High School.