Why register?

make an anime and manga list, and more! all free!

Theme

Death Note Review

by: sothis
November 22, 2009

story 4/10

Death Note screenshot

When it comes to Death Note, the masses have spoken: it's a groundbreaking, gripping tale of deceit and intrigue that will keep you at the edge of your seat from start to end. With one of the highest average ratings on Anime-Planet and a level of hype that treads dangerously close to that of Naruto, Death Note has been deemed a "must-see", a "triumph", and "a series that no anime fan should be without".

Except that it’s not.

I’m not sure if my perception of reality is fatally flawed or if Death Note’s prominent mainstream presence has blinded the masses, but I just don’t get it. Death Note is a good anime, though it’s not the best and has a rash of insidious problems that most reviews tend to miss. Now, I'm aware that the majority of readers likely want to murder me, but put down the butcher knife for a second and hear me out.

Death Note starts out promising a thrilling ride to come. Teenager Light Yagami finds a mysterious book that a shinigami ‘carelessly’ drops into the human world, but it holds a dangerous secret: any person whose name is written within dies. Almost immediately the boy decides to exact his own brand of justice on criminals, thugs and others that are expendable in the name of a better world, quickly catching the attention of the authorities. Meanwhile, the general population both admires and fears this unknown assailant, giving he or she the nickname of Kira. Light's primary antagonist is L, a secretive, genius detective who vows to put a stop to Kira's reign of terror. With intellectual grace and precision the two begin a deadly game of cat and mouse where move after move is calculated, and each attempts to unmask the other first.

I won't deny that fans of psychological warfare will find the above premise engaging and exciting, and had the series ended after this first arc, I would have deemed it a smashing success. However, after building up a great deal of suspense, Death Note stumbles into its second segment with a confusing transition that isn't explained until a dozen episodes later. Almost this entire arc follows Light and the detectives as they investigate a shadowy organization that no viewer will give a shit about, and Light and L's intense dance is tossed by the wayside. Perhaps the only redeeming element of this part of the story is a powerful climax that will leave you saddened yet moved, but any non-delusional anime fan should be disgusted with what comes next: a third arc so offensively bad that I was reminded of Gantz - an otherwise powerful anime that also should have known when to quit. A whole new cast of characters appears, filling copycat roles that bring nothing new to the mix. At this point, those who aren't under the influence of fanboyism should feel any old emotional bonds they had with Death Note evaporating into thin air. By the series' end, I cared almost nothing for any of the characters, and felt relief only when the finale credits rolled; but an acceptable ending couldn't save Death Note's disappointing decline into mediocrity, regardless of how powerful the first arc was.

One other important note is one of the series' most irritating qualities: the ENDLESS, ENDLESS INTERNAL MONOLOGUING which begins almost immediately and doesn’t let up till the final episode. If you think shounen titles such as Naruto and Dragon Ball Z are bad, just wait until you see Death Note. Every single action and reaction is thoroughly analyzed internally or out loud by Light, L and damn near everyone else in the cast, followed by yet another just-as-long diatribe about what the speaker would then do next. AND THIS HAPPENS FOR THIRTY SEVEN EPISODES. Not since Ghost in the Shell: Innocence have I wanted so badly for the characters to shut the fuck up and move on. In a way, it feels like Death Note's creators were pandering to the lowest common denominator of intelligence by so grossly overstating the obvious mental leaps. Were Light and L truly as brilliant as they seem, they shouldn't need five minutes to compose every thought they have.

I'm open to hearing other opinions on why Death Note's plot is awesome enough to deserve a 15 out of 10 score, but with two throwaway, boring, copycat arcs and other problems I can't see how any anime fan in good conscience can say such a thing.

animation 6.5/10

Death Note's animation is hailed as being exceptional in every way; once again, I don't get it. The series' dark imagery provides a pleasing appearance, but the character designs look sloppy (specifically the facial linework and simplicity) and still sequences mar the experience far too often. Furthermore, frequently L and Light change color and deliver a multi-minute monologue as the camera creeps slowly across the screen, and the rest of the series tends to fare just as poorly. Death Note's definition of 'animation' apparently takes a page from the book of lazy.

Still, most viewers will likely appreciate Death Note's animation and consider it perfectly acceptable for a modern anime. Movement - when it actually occurs - flows wonderfully, and the shinigami world is depicted with a perfect combination of desolation and intrigue. Other visually impressive elements include the 'life counters' floating above people's heads, and the eerie red glow of 'shinigami eyes.'

sound 8/10

Death Note's first opening track is forgettable, but the second shines - well actually, it growls and screams. I think this is the first time I've heard a thrash metal track used as an anime's intro, and in this case it works perfectly. Combined with frantic, crazed shots of Light, this intro truly is a herald of things to come, and helps accentuate his madness. Overall the background score perfectly complements the suspense and intrigue, delivering a handful of orchestral, church-like tracks that grow on you throughout the series. While Death Note doesn't have much going for it, the music is hands down awesome.

characters 6/10

Love him or hate him, Light is one evil dude. From the get-go he's painted as a teen with a god complex who teeters between reality and insanity, and this persona rings true for the entirety of the series. Light is not a saint, nor does he have any hope of redemption; each move he makes is manipulating, sinister and self-serving to the core, justifying him as the ultimate anti-hero. You'll generally both cheer along as he executes the scum of the world and cringe as you watch people get stepped on along the way. Light's twisted, deranged view of his utopia damages everyone around him and in general, his personality is one of the best aspects of Death Note.

Counterpart to Light is L, a fiendish, quirky detective whose bizarre mannerisms and actions provide some of the series' (perhaps unintentional) comic relief. L wasn't developed as much as I'd hoped, and only near the end of the anime do you learn about his history. Still, his character comes across as a bit one-dimensional and should have been more fully fleshed out. Then again, he exists mostly as the protagonist - or antagonist - against Light, and their battle of wits is enjoyable to watch. One thing's for sure, not since Evangelion has there been such a firm division in fanboyism between those who swear by Light, and others who pledge their allegiance to L.

Last but not least there's Ryuk, a shinigami (death god) who quietly tags along with Light as he inflicts his wrath on the world. Ryuk doesn't judge, and he doesn't stop Light's actions, no matter how ill-conveived. In fact, the shinigami often chuckles creepily when the boy unknowingly makes a mistake or does something exceptionally evil; the supernatural being bides his time until he gets what he wants: Light's soul. Unfortunately Ryuk only stays in the spotlight strongly in the first arc; during the second he is out of the picture, returning in the third as a minor actor. It's too bad, as he provides the only other source of comic relief with his obsession with apples.

Several secondary characters also take the limelight at times, evoking a variety of emotions. Light's father, refusing to believe his son could be the killer, made me angry out of empathy. Misa, one of Light's admirers, is whiny and ditzy to the point that I wanted to punch her in the face. And Mello, one of the later characters in the series, prompted more anger - this time at the series' creators for not coming up with someone more original. While each of these and more grace the screen and take hold of the conversation at times, none are developed enough to really care about.

overall 5.8/10

Originally I planned on giving Death Note an overall rating of 6 to 6.5, but after carefully thinking about all of its faults versus strengths, I can't in good conscience award such a high score. A good first dozen episodes (flaws aside) does not a groundbreaking series make, and the consistent and escalating flaws ultimately condemn Death Note to being a good, but not great, anime. I understand that the masses are unable or unwilling to find fault with such a highly-revered title, but in my opinion that's a dishonest stance. There's no denying that the second arc is poorly tacked onto the first, that the third is nothing but a bad carbon copy, and that the thrill level wildly oscillates between high-octane and boredom; so why is Death Note constantly referred to as the best thing on the planet?

To each their own I suppose, I just know that Death Note - even without the hype - was a big time disappointment for me. I wish the creators had done the humane thing by euthanizing it sooner, rather than insulting the viewers' intelligence with endless, overdone 'intellectual analyzing.'

Important note: feel free to respond with your own feelings about the series, but given how volitile I know this review will be I need to remind each reader to keep this thread in mind. Personal attacks on any reviews or reviewers (rather than one's own opinion of the anime) will be removed, and may result in the removal of commenting ability.

Anime Info

Have you ever felt like the world would be a better place if certain people weren’t around? Such grim daydreams might occur when watching the dismal daily news, but on one fateful day, Light Yagami finds that these daydreams can become reality. By pure happenstance, he comes across a black notebook entitled "Death Note", whose text within states that whoever's name is written on its pages will die. With the aid of the death god Ryuk, Light takes it upon himself to rid the world of its corruption, ushering in a new era of purity one death at a time. But as Ryuk foretells, Light's actions will not go unchallenged...

my anime:

not rated

About the Author

sothis's avatar

sothis

My fav genres include sci fi and horror, but you'll find a lot of obscure reviews from me too, given I watch a ton to add to the database. My new reviews are written a lot better than my old ones, so when in doubt, sort by date! ^_^ Enjoy, and I welcome any and all feedback.

More Reviews

comments

Alroskil avatar Alroskil
Aug 3, 2011

See, here's the thing about Death Note- I pretty much agree- the first arc was great, and it just kind of fell apart after that. However, I completely disagree with the characterization- I found Ryuk interesting at first, but then kind of got bored when he never really added that much to the story. He was just a plot device and nothing else. I feel the opposite of what you do regarding L and Light. L isn't fleshed out in any obvious sense, but I'd argue that there is some dimension and development there, if you pay rather close attention and read between some lines. Light, meanwhile, really doesn't develop much at all. He's a sociopathic, incredibly intelligent, teenager, wanting to create change in the world by becoming its ruler. That's... about it. No real character development, no real fleshing out. That's all we get. That's all he is. As one of the two main characters, it's actually kind of disappointing. The only thing that causes you to avoid notices it for the first arc is the rather tight pacing and interesting story. After that...

Also, this raised serious eyebrows. (I could comment on most of bidomino's post, but that would be too massive of a wall.)

"Disparaging Death Note on the basis of the second and third arcs is tantamount to proclaiming, 'I don't like anime.'"

I really hate to use memes, but seriously... lolwut? No. No it isn't. Death  Note Arc #2 goes on a tangent, suddenly switching the antagonist after a climatic point, and the story loses much of its focus. It doesn't help that instead of an equally intelligent foe, they're simply dealing with an average human being- so it feels a bit drawn out too. Much of the second arc isn't interesting, simply because there isn't as much tension about whether or not they'll find a way to convict the culprits as there was with L's battles with Light. This is the kind of person L has caught time and time again, with another incredibly intelligent person at his side- it's just utterly anti-climatic.

And don't get me started on Arc #3. Timeskips are almost ALWAYS a bad sign in the middle of an anime.

I love anime. I've watched a lot of anime. I would actually argue that it's worth giving a shot based on the first arc, despite a few problems I had with it. Arcs #2 and #3 make the judgment "completely overrated" very viable.

It's rather similar to Code Geass, although that was as good (if not better) for longer, and retained its quality for an entire series, so I'm not sure how viable the comparison is. I might just want to make it because the shows premises are also so similar.

animegirl99 avatar animegirl99
Jul 17, 2011

Thank you for saying that it sucks!! but to be honest i dropped it before the second arc i just got tired of it. I really think that the anime sucks.

leti avatar leti
Jul 15, 2011

Love IT!!One of the best Anime i have ever watched!!c;

LeaT avatar LeaT
Jun 14, 2011

To be quite honest, I dropped Death Note even before the second arc. As much as I think the premise of the story is great and Light works very well as the main character, the problem with Death Note is that it barely gets anywhere, ever. I've read up to about tankubon 6 or 7, and I watched about half of the first season and I don't feel I need to read/see more. Why? Because at that point the intellectual battles between Light and L become really boring, especially since they add nothing in particular to the story - the intellectual battles seem to almost be there for the sake of being there. Also, as a person with at least average IQ it becomes obvious that neither Light nor L are as smart as they are presented as. This is a great character flaw and a problem whenever an author attempts to make a character appear smarter than the rest of the population. The problem is that the character's intelligence will always be limited by the author's intelligence, and therefore as the series goes on the intellectual battles feel more and more convoluted and contrived in poor attempts of coming off as "innovative" and "original".

That L never really receives any real character development is also really detrimental to the series, because as we continue to watch Light slowly turning mad, we need L to be there as support so we can turn to L and say, well Light is completely nuts now, and it turns out L wasn't such a bad guy for trying to stop him after all. However, with the way the story is told it just never happens.

I love the idea of Death Note and the very beginning is great when it feels fresh and interesting - after that it slowly goes straight down to hell in its failure to maintain that feeling of freshness. Pseudo-intellectualism may impress the very impressionable, but not the actual intellectuals. If Death Note had attempted to go somewhere else after its initial detective story, maybe that of mystery or psychological horror, it had worked out great. The problem is, it never did.

SadisticTendencies avatar SadisticTendencies
May 26, 2011

My god, give it a rest with the fanboyism! Personally I'd say 'Death Note' deserves somewhere around 7, but it is definitely flawed. Besides, the last arc is a complete disaster of hastily introducted characters and uninteresting mayhem.

You must be logged in to leave review comments. Login or sign up today!