Why register?

make an anime and manga list, and more! all free!

Theme

Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade Review

by: Sheex
June 5, 2008

story 6/10

Jin-Roh: The Wolf Brigade screenshot

Going in to Jin-Roh I really had no idea what to expect.  Oddly enough, one hundred minutes later, these sentiments have hardly changed.  Indeed, the movie is spectacular in many respects, but likewise it seems to have a strew of perpetual weaknesses that hinder its ability to achieve greatness.

First off, the movie's opening is superb.  It starts off with a relatively simple explanation of a divided, post World War II Japan, then smoothly transitions into a tense riot situation.  Thrusting you into the midst of flying molotov cocktails, a whirl of stones and rocks, and exploding canisters of tear gas, it's undeniably captivating, and serves as a great hook-line-sinker introduction.  Furthermore, the scene ends brilliantly with the tragic death of a young teenage girl who, out of fear, detonates a satchel bomb and kills herself when caught by a team of riot police.

Yet, right after this event, the movie takes a sudden shift in both setting and direction.  It follows the story of Fuse, the man who was closest to the girl when she detonated the bomb, and his emotional struggles in the aftermath of the event; however, this abrupt change of pace causes the movie to stumble a bit, as Fuse's complete lack of personality makes it hard to empathize with him.  As such, it drifts dangerously close to borderline boredom, but somehow manages to still keep viewer interest by use of a twisted Little Red Riding Hood narrative.  The somewhat macabre undertones of this story continually hint at a tense, bloody ending, and perhaps that expectation gave me the motivation to see it all the way through.

Thankfully, to compensate for the droll nature of its middle section, the movie ends with a bang as promised.  Though the primary villains' motivations are never really explained with any semblance of detail, the climax provides Fuse's social shortcomings with purpose - and in quite an entertaining fashion.  Just like its opening sequence, Jin-Roh revisits its angst-driven combat scenes for one last go, culminating with a bittersweet ending scene that brings the movie to a satisfactory close.  While it doesn't completely make up for its pacing issues, in retrospect it makes them worth tolerating, as, ultimately, the movie left me with a positive feeling.

animation 7.5/10

Though, overall, the entire movie looked splendid, the character designs irked me.  Despite not being entirely bad, they were very simplistic in design, and at times their lack of detail coincided poorly with the enormously lavish backgrounds.  Of these flaws, the women in particular could have used a lot of polish, as I had a hard time distinguishing them from the men for much of the movie.  Even so, the Special Unit armor suits didn't suffer this flaw, so I can't say all the designs were bad.  By-in-large the movie's visuals were more than acceptable, so I'm hesitant to say anything else that might denigrate your perception further; for an eight year old movie, it certainly doesn't disappoint. 

sound 6/10

Yet, while the animation might have aged well, I can't say the same about the audio score.  Much of the music was rather unremarkable in quality, and for the vast majority of the time I hardly even noticed its presence.  Worse yet, though, and admittedly this was likely somewhat intentional, the voice acting was utterly devoid of emotional flavor.  While the actors were not bad per se, their lack of involvement contributed rather substantially to my waning interest during the scenes devoid of action.  Overall, I think this probably resulted from poorly scripted dialogue, though, as much as it did from performance. 

characters 5/10

If I've ever come across a pair of lead characters who have proven just how devoid of personality a human being can be, Fuse and his no-name (or if she had one I don't remember) love interest would stake that claim.  There is, quite literally, absolutely nothing to say about either character - ultimately they come across as musings of the plot and nothing more.  In context they aren't bad, but neither are they either particularly good or memorable.

overall 6.5/10

Even so, overall Jin-Roh is a decent movie.  While not too terribly memorable, for its run time it's entertaining irrespective of its minor boredom quirks.  It carries an overall mature air that grants it a sense of respectability, and for that I think it merits consideration - especially for an older audience.

Anime Info

  • Movie (1 ep x 102 min)
  • 2000

Constable Fuse is part of an elite Special Forces unit known as the Capital Police whose mission is to maintain peace during a time of civil unrest. Fuse becomes entangled within a web of intrigue and politics between the Capital Police, the government intelligence bureau, and a secret society known as Jin-Roh – the Wolf Brigade.


( ! ) Warning: Unterminated comment starting line 1 in /home/anime/templates/right_join_reviewer_box.php on line 1
Call Stack
#TimeMemoryFunctionLocation
10.02634534880{main}( )../entry.php:0
20.03824836040include( '/home/anime/public_html/reviews/anime_entry.php' )../entry.php:18

my anime:

not rated

About the Author

Sheex's avatar

Sheex

Though I'm a big fan of slice of life and romance, I'll watch just about anything that catches my interest. My opinions tend to be pretty level-headed, but I have been known to be controversial from time to time! Feel free to lay into me if you so desire, as I always appreciate feedback - positive or negative. I hope you enjoy reading!

More Reviews

comments

Singan avatar Singan
Dec 8, 2012

I don't want to criticize this review and other comments concerning the story because it's a typical reaction of most viewers first time they watch Jin-Roh. In fact, my first reaction was pretty similar to this before I rewatched it. Also, it has to do with subjective taste, and tastes are naturally different.

But seriously, 6 points for the sound? The theme song of this movie (Grace Omega) is simply fantastic. I suggest anyone look up this song and wonder how it may possibly be "unremarkable in quality" regardless of personal tastes. The rest of the music is very good too, and even if you don't like the voice acting, it's not a reason to drop the score so low.

The same for animation: it may be rather specific in terms of style, but it's undoubtedly excellent in terms of quality: the whole movie is hand-drawn and very detailed, and not even once I thought about its age. As for character designs, I presume they're just realistic - asian people looking like real Asians without any ugliness unlike, say, the characters in Akira.

I'm not a Jin-Roh fan - just think a bit of objectivity won't harm anyone)

darczon69 avatar darczon69
Sep 6, 2011

I just finished watching the movie and I must say I enjoyed it very much. True, the lack of character development was...disappointing, but all in all, Jin-Roh is an excellent late night movie, with just the right amount of action, angst and moral dilemmas. The Little Red Riding Food...I mean Hood also added a pretty macabre touch to the movie.

One more thing...does anyone know where can I get one of those costumes? :D

Ravenx avatar Ravenx
Jun 23, 2011

I'd say this movie is a lot of average/dull and a few sparkles of enticement. All around the movie is pretty average and most elements are simply forgettable. Characters barely have charm, devoid of depth or personality, so we are never really intrigued by their motivations or even really care for them. Since the story is nothing groundbreaking, both the most important elements already drag it to a halt. I'd say its best aspect is animation, even if it's not top notch.

I got this movie, only watched it once because of this.

Assiman avatar Assiman
Dec 18, 2009

I don't really understand why this movie is so respected and hyped. I just watched it and I'm little bit dissapointed with it actually. Maybe I was expecting a realistic drama or something... I mostly agree with this review, except that I actually liked the minimalistic audio score a lot.

Great review.

madcomic avatar madcomic
Aug 7, 2009

Not sure if I would have wanted to read this review prior to viewing the movie. But reading it after viewing the movie I realy think the same way you do. It's actualy a rather slow or normal paced movie with a great action intro and ending.

You must be logged in to leave review comments. Login or sign up today!