Why register?

make an anime and manga list, and more! all free!

Theme

Ergo Proxy Review

July 2, 2007

story 3.5/10

Ergo Proxy screenshot

Ergo Proxy’s storyline is a disaster. A hopeless, irredeemable disaster.

No one will deny the incredible ambition of this series. The production values, for one, are on par with the best that modern anime studios have to offer. The storyline is epic, sweeping, and complex. Moreover, multitudes of challenging and varied themes are woven into the science-fiction narrative. At arm’s length, Ergo Proxy looks, feels and smells like it could be a defining classic of this decade.

Instead, Ergo Proxy is a tragic disappointment, an almost comically inept failure. The show will bore and confuse the watchers who are unwilling to turn their Saturday afternoon into an English Lit. assignment, and insult the few who are. For all its high and lofty intentions, watching Ergo Proxy is, in the series’ own pompous rhetoric, a zero-sum game.

The identity of self. The nature of reality. Society’s addiction to technology. Life as a zero-sum game. The afterlife. Artificial intelligence. The existence of a soul. The existence of God. The raison d'êtres of individuals and societies. The unreliability of the senses. The bestial nature of humanity. Society’s Fear of the Other. The callousness of evolution. The inhumanity of intellectualism. Human fallibility. Genetic engineering. Machiavellianism. Existential ANGST!

Most brainy sci-fi shows have the good sense to pick one or two of the above themes and then explore them in detail. Ergo Proxy, on the other hand, touches on every single one without ever seriously delving into any of them. The result is clumsy, unorganized and shallow. In the end, the show plays more like a greatest hits compilation of better sci-fi titles before it than a legitimately standalone work of art. Those trying to cast the show in a good light might call Ergo Proxy “eclectic” – personally, I prefer “bloated.”

Also, like Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence, Ergo Proxy feels the inexplicable need to bludgeon its viewers with countless literary references – references that are often largely irrelevant to the actual storyline and add little to the overarching narrative. The resulting allusion profusion makes the show seem more like a classroom assignment than a work of entertainment.

Perhaps because of the endless plethora of themes and allusions, Ergo Proxy’s pacing is turgid and inept. Only a handful of plot details are revealed in a given episode, and even those are slowly squeezed out, like turds through a tightly puckered sphincter. The rest of an episode’s time is taken up in leaden dialogue (or even worse, monologue) that goes absolutely nowhere.

animation 7/10

The visuals are competent, if not spectacular. The series adheres to its dark, nearly monochromatic palette almost religiously, deviating only in rare and effective moments. This gothic style, more than anything else, is probably the animation’s biggest strength.

Unfortunately, other parts are decidedly lacking. The character designs definitely leave something to be desired; in particular, Real Mayer’s eye-shadowed face is ugly and unappealing. Also, the action scenes are often underwhelming and unimpressive, albeit never actively bad.

sound 8.5/10

Frankly, Ergo Proxy has a much better soundtrack than it deserves. Both the OP and ED are fantastic rock tracks, and the background music is wonderfully moody ambient that works extremely well with the show.

Voice acting is fairly monotone due to the nature of the show, but is fine regardless.

characters 3/10

Like other experimental science fiction shows, Ergo Proxy just has too much weighty storyline to really spend time on creating interesting, fully fleshed out characters. However, unlike other shows, the plot isn’t good enough to make up for the shallow, one-dimensional characterization. Rather, the weakness of the storyline only serves to bring out how terribly uninteresting each character actually is. Real Mayer is one of the most vapid, underdeveloped protagonists that I’ve seen in recent memory, and the rest are only marginally better.

overall 4.5/10

Granted, several isolated episodes are creative and interesting, and there are few series out there as ambitious as this one. As a whole, however, one gets the impression that rather than the creators setting out to make an anime that meant something, they were content to make the series just look as intelligent as possible. When all is said and done, Ergo Proxy doesn't know what to say, so it ends up saying little at all.

Anime Info

In a futuristic world almost barren of life, mankind is confined to mechanized domed cities where A.I.’s control all aspects of life. In this world, humans are no longer born, they are manufactured in a production line; and alongside them live androids known as autoreivs. Within one of these domed sanctuaries named Romdeau lives Re-l Mayer, one of a few citizens who aren’t entirely prevented from thinking. Her grandfather's prominent position and the affection of the scientist Daedalus have left her more free will than is normally allowed, but Re-l has started to question the sanctity of the city and the citizens' perfect way of life. With mysterious beings known as proxies causing havoc and a man named Vincent causing great influence on her life, Re-l must travel outside of the city to find the answers she seeks and discover the mystery behind "the awakening".


( ! ) Warning: Unterminated comment starting line 1 in /home/anime/templates/right_join_reviewer_box.php on line 1
Call Stack
#TimeMemoryFunctionLocation
10.03074535400{main}( )../entry.php:0
20.04624836800include( '/home/anime/public_html/reviews/anime_entry.php' )../entry.php:18

my anime:

not rated

comments

PyroDrone avatar PyroDrone
Oct 25, 2009

Hmmm.  I loved the storyline and the characters.  Its so very subtle.  And I love that passive subconscious understanding you gain, if you have a close eye.  It's definitely a slow paced thinker.  But if you're an intellectual with a big radar, you'll love the series.  Also the recommendations for the series seem right on.

Burabura avatar Burabura
Oct 15, 2009

A review is never going to be objective, but I do find the rating 4.5/10 a little too harsh for this series. The visuals, alone, should take it above the halfway mark. Granted, this series does have an undeniably slow narrative pace -- but, it is successful in the fact that it raises questions. It's a delve into clashing philosophies of personal identity, conscience, and the ever-prevalent question of consciousness. Do not let this review sway you from watching this series. I believe any sci-fi fan should sit down with a cup of tea and mull over the main themes within Ergo Proxy. These are the questions that plague us to this day. These are the questions that will plague us tomorrow, the day after, and for years into the future. 

It's not the best series ever made, but it's worth your time. Go into the series expecting absolutely nothing and come out of it pensively, slowly...

default avatar requerent
Oct 10, 2009

Your expectation and disappointment is weighted too heavily in your score, instead of an objective perspective.

The plot and character development of Ergo Proxy is really quite clever, brilliant and interesting. The pedantic lessons on philosophy are the ONLY real hindrance to the plot/character development, and more often than not they aren't nearly as poorly done as you suggest. The pacing is enough to scratch your eyeballs out... as someone with a firm understanding of western philosophy will find this boring and someone who does not will remain ignorant/confused, but despite this, the Plot and CD only suffer from the pacing of so much junk being mixed in.

The premise is a little abstract, but overall very cool. Identity recreation by creating an instance of oneself so that it may transcend one's own limitations and destroy the prior self; I was impressed and found the ending to be very satisying. Proxy One knew exactly what he was doing, and everything that happened in the series was engineered according to his flawlessly executed plan, which only becomes more interesting as it is revealed (though, this interest can be killed, again, by the pacing).

I think the reviewer is missing what the series has to offer and is instead declaring that the philosophical eye-candy was the primary excuse for production. I would say that this isn't so, for when you truly understand what is going on, in terms of the plot, it's a satisfying show.

It can't be denied that MOST of it should've been cut. A more judicious editor would've made this series fantastic.

Nuri avatar Nuri
Oct 4, 2009

Most of the things in Ergo Proxy may very well fly over the viewers head, which is why I was glad that at the end they typed out what each episodes symbolic "ornaments" (I guess you could say) meant. Overall though it was enjoyable, the last episode was a bit of a downer for me; but overall it was a good watch at least for me.

Poorrichard avatar Poorrichard
Sep 27, 2009

I really liked this anime, especially the opening title and song. Good animation throughout. In the characters, I kept expecting Real Mayer to come through with some life lessons, but I could not rsee any real growth in the character, except maybe a little smaller chip on her shoulder.  The real focus, it seems, was on Ergo Proxy himself, and he did grow as a character.

Overall, though some things could have been done better in characterization, the series was enjoyable. I REALLY liked the opening title and song.

You must be logged in to leave review comments. Login or sign up today!