Why register?

make an anime and manga list, and more! all free!


Ibara no Okite

Alt titles: Thorny Rules

Ibara no Okite Cover Image
  • Vol: 1; Ch: 4
  • 2008
3.829 out of 5 from 34 votes
Rank #2,397


In the castle of Earl Craven, all the maids, including the lovely Priscilla, are strictly forbidden from ever looking their master in the eye. This is because the man they serve is none other than the detestable Demon King! But he's not a demon at all, and isn't even slightly evil, a fact that Priscilla learns when she accidentally runs into her employer in town. Over time, the girl becomes infatuated with the charming young man, but is terrified to reveal her true identity. After all, who would ever accept the love between a maid and an Earl?


my manga:

not rated
add recs
Name Role
Yuni YUKIMURA Artist
Yuni YUKIMURA Author

Community Reviews

You must be a registered user to add reviews. Login or sign up today!

No community reviews found.

List Title Username Entries Date
LOVE these!! Brightstone 10 Feb 26, 2014
Manga Synopses I Wrote AirCommodore 67 Nov 7, 2012
xocorinne27 wants to read Ibara no Okite
Denerok rated the Ibara no Okite manga 5/5 stars
Denerok read Ibara no Okite at 1 of 1 volumes
Roxyslife read Ibara no Okite at 1 of 1 volumes
rcatad rated the Ibara no Okite manga 5/5 stars

Recommendations if you like Ibara no Okite

0 filtered - clear filters



In the late 19th Century, England was effectively split into two ‘countries' - that of the aristocratic and rich, and all those below them. One day William Jones, the young son of a rich merchant, pays a visit to his former governess Mrs Stowmar. When he arrives, there is an instant connection between him and Emma, the hard-working and beautiful young maid who works there. After several chance encounters their attraction deepens, but their difference in social status is something which cannot be ignored. With William's father refusing to give his consent to their relationship and intent on arranging a marriage for him with Eleanor, the daughter of a Viscount, there are an increasing number of obstacles standing in their way. In a society where the relationship between a humble maid and a gentleman is forbidden and one is expected to marry within their social rank, can Emma and William's love survive?

my list:

not rated
I agree...
2 people agree

Emma is way way way better, but both of these manga are about a romance between a lowly maid and a man from a wealthy, well-to-do family. Needless to say, the man's family/other relations does NOT approve of their relationship, and the two face a lot of conflict because of their differing social status.

If you liked Ibara no Okite, definitely check out Emma. For Emma fans- Ibara no Okite is pretty fluffy shoujo, and nowhere as deep/interesting as Emma, but if you're looking for a light, quick read with similar themes, it might be up your alley.


"Ibara no Okite" is "Emma"-lite. It has none of the mature themes which make up "Emma," and the artwork in "Emma" is far superior. However, since both manga are about a forbidden romance between a maid and a man of nobility, they are good recommendations.

Suki ni Naru Made Matte

Suki ni Naru Made Matte
  • Vol: 1; Ch: 4
  • 2007

my list:

not rated
I agree...
1 person agrees

Another short and super-fluffy shoujo romance about forbidden love. Due to their social status/jobs, the characters in both must keep their relationship a secret.