Why register?

make an anime and manga list, and more! all free!

Theme

Good-bye

Good-bye Cover Image
  • Vol: 1; Ch: 9
  • 1973
Avg
3.685 out of 5 from 18 votes
Rank #3,121
recommendations

user stats

Synopsis:

Life proves again and again that you must accept the cards you are dealt, whether you live in a post-war era or are about to retire. From a woman in a relationship with an American soldier at the end of World War II, to a soon-to-retire man who conspires revenge against his long-time wife, to a man with a fetish for legs and shoes who tries to continue a façade of normality, and beyond, each denizen of Japan will tell their melancholic story of what is important to them.

my manga:

not rated
add recs
Name Role
Yoshihiro TATSUMI Artist
Yoshihiro TATSUMI Author

Community Reviews

You must be a registered user to add reviews. Login or sign up today!

No community reviews found.

List Title Username Entries Date
Manga that I own AirCommodore 58 Sep 6, 2011
XxAnimeFreak4EvrXx wants to read Good-bye
Regret rated the Good-bye manga 4/5 stars
Regret read Good-bye at 1 of 1 volumes
nonononono read Good-bye at 1 of 1 volumes
SpaceDaiGun wants to read Good-bye

Recommendations if you like Good-bye

0 filtered - clear filters

Abandon the Old in Tokyo

Abandon the Old in Tokyo

Tokyo is a bustling metropolis filled with life, catering to both successful businessmen and the down and out alike. From a man who’s shackled to life because of his ailing mother to a tale of a struggling mangaka, humanity’s darker moments are revealed with sadness and shame. Whether it’s the tale of a man and his monkey or the vengeful feelings of a disfigured woman, many dreams and stories are told with insight and empathy.

my list:

not rated
I agree...
1 person agrees
sothis

Two compilations of older gekiga manga by the same author, Yoshihiro Tatsumi. While it's generally cliche to recommend something because it's the same author, Tatsumi's stories tend to be very similar: lots of dark themes, lots of sex, a pretty dismal outlook on society, and lots of unfinished ends (plenty of the stories in both compilations just 'end' without much closure, or flat out don't make sense). If you liked the style or tone of one, you will enjoy the other.

A Drifting Life

A Drifting Life

In the mid 20th century, young Hiroshi found himself enamored with manga – especially works created by Osamu Tezuka. With a strong desire to publish his own works, Hiroshi picked up a pen and began a lifelong journey to live up to his role model. Through disappointments and triumphs, Hiroshi continued on to help birth a new form of manga, as the history of the medium unfolded around him…

my list:

not rated
I agree...
1 person agrees
AirCommodore

If you like the art or tone in either of these manga by Yoshihiro Tatsumi, I encourage you to check out the other. A Drifting Life is autobiographical, whereas Good-Bye is a collection of short (fictional) stories, but both will interest you if you're interested in Tatsumi's work, historical manga, or gekiga.

Imo-mushi

Imo-mushi

A man returns home limbless, mute, and disfigured after sustaining severe injuries during his service in the Russo-Japanese war. Though she is repulsed by him, his wife does her duty and nurses her husband, attempting to tolerate his sexual appetite and make his cruel life as pleasant as possible. But after a few years this repulsion turns to loathing, and then to abuse, as the woman begins to take out her frustrations and stress on the man...

my list:

not rated
I agree...
1 person agrees
AirCommodore

These manga have fairly similar themes- if you like super depressing stories about post-war eras, check both of them out (word of warning- Imo-mushi is way more explicit).

Red Snow

Red Snow

Many farmers, workers and housewives live eventful lives in pre-modern rural Japan. A man's daughter is being taken advantage of each night by a mysterious spirit, a young boy is intrigued by a mistress's daughter, even though his interest is usually met with a closed fist, and an old woman known as Young Bride is taunted by everyone in her village, amongst other tales.

my list:

not rated
I agree...
1 person agrees
sothis

Two gekiga compilations of stories that tend to be short, end abruptly, or end dismally. Plot-wise they aren't similar (Good-bye focusing on WW2, Red Snow on pre-modern Japan), but they definitely have a similar vibe.

Town of Evening Calm, Country of Cherry Blossoms

Town of Evening Calm, Country of Cherry Blossoms

Even those that survived the atomic bombing of Hiroshima couldn't escape its repercussions. Ten years after that fateful day, blast survivors still struggle with lingering radiation exposure and squalid living conditions. During this time, Minami Hirano ignores her worsening physical condition and tries to live her life as best she can, despite being haunted by what she saw and how she reacted during the event. Then, fifty years in the future, the city has been rebuilt and the radiation has subsided, but the ghost of the tragedy still looms in the minds of those that were left behind.

my list:

not rated
I agree...
1 person agrees
AirCommodore

This recommendation especially applies to the first story in each of these books, both of which are about the devastation and after-effects of the nuclear bombing in Hiroshima.

Aside from that, both somberly detail the post-WWII era, refusing to water anything down. Children will undoubtedly find both of these manga very boring and/or incomprehensible.