10/25/08 - Vote on This Week's Theme Submissions: Hero

[xXYoruichiXx]

Information
---------------------------------------------
These signatures are the submissions for the theme of the week contest. The signatures are not listed in any particular order. Please vote in the poll for the signature you think is the best. You will have until Midnight PST on Saturday, 11/01/08, to vote. Only one vote per person. If you would like to discuss the submissions, you may do so in this thread. Thanks and happy voting!


Theme and Content Type
---------------------------------------------
Hero, Anime


Submissions
---------------------------------------------

1.
Submitted by: EvilMewMew - Forum - Site

The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya

2.
Submitted by: lv23 - Forum - Site

Gundam 00

3.
Submitted by: foureyedalice - Forum - Site

Revolutionary Girl Utena

****Voting is now over****

Thank you to everyone that entered the contest and voted. :)

Signature 2, lv23 is the winner!

[Kenikki]

I like all three, but there are some things I also dislike about all of them.

The first one seems to be the best made one, but I don't like the colors of the background and the "hero" part is blocked på the sidebar.

The second one doesn't look like it has much work behind it, but it fits very well with the A-P sig style.

The third one is also very nice, but it's too bad that a lot of her face gets blocked by the time-bar.

So, to conclude, #2 is my choice, because it simply looks the best when the A-P bars are attached.

[Eriol]

I agree with what Kenikki said, but I can't really vote for anything Gundam. I'll have to go with one, even though it has the problems with different sig styles.

[al2551]

I vote #2. I appeals to me the most regardless of its technical aspects.

[KiraRin]

I was too busy with work this week and missed the deadline, so couldn't enter mine :cry:



But #2, I choose you!

H.

[rockenroll4life]

I would have liked to have voted for 1 but I couldn't cause hero's gets cut out. I ended up going with 2 cause its the only one that first well in the sig format.

As a side note to submitters. Try photoshopping up the sig format or getting a hold of it. It helps so you know what your actual sig will look like and you can work it to fit in them. It's better then not getting far because you messed up a little and something was cut off. ^_^

Good job over all pre siggy format though.

[catzilla]

I guess we have a trend for number one and two. I really liked number one as well but number two went with the sig format much nicer...

[arc666]

2.

[Gallarn]

#2

[Sesetsu]

I think I'll go with number 2.


#1 Its a nice sig and the person put a good amount of effort into it but I found that the background was just a bit to over saturated for me. Other then that the only other fault I can think of off the top of my head is that there is a few small spots of random brushing over the render. This normally wouldn't be a problem or would help blend the render but it just seems out of place. All in all its a good piece but fell short of being my choice.

#2 Although I chose this one it wont escape. This one was overall the most visually pleasing of the group. Although it was best overall it also looked to have the least amount of work behind it. I can't be entirely sure about this as I do not know how the source images them selves looked before being implemented. The creator may have very well put allot of work into this and I could just be saying nothing. But it looks to me its nothing but a well chosen BG with a good render slapped in front of it with a bit or brushing underneath it. Even so the end result was great some times simplicity is best route and for this the sig gets my vote.

#3 For this one the only real problem I find with it is the fact so much of the characters face is cut off while placed under the template other then that its a great sig. the Bg is a bit simple but like I said above sometimes simplicity is good and over all its a good work.