Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica

[Kenikki]

Originally Posted by Verified

I dunno, that first girl that is saved, her soul gem looked like it was about to go witch. And unless Madoka has the best timing ever, that girl was in the past and had already turned into a witch. Madoka obliterated all witches from the past, present, and future taking on the "despair" that was equal to the hope the girls received for their wishes.

I need to watch these last two a second time a lot needs to be studied

Right, Madoka absorbed all the grief from all the mahou shoujos who had turned to witches and then blew up that entire collection. But the mahou shoujos didn't live on, they disappeared, not even leaving a body behind.

That first girl was "saved" in the sense that she didn't get turned into a witch, but she did disappear.

[MugiwaraMarius]

Originally Posted by Verified

I dunno, that first girl that is saved, her soul gem looked like it was about to go witch. And unless Madoka has the best timing ever, that girl was in the past and had already turned into a witch. Madoka obliterated all witches from the past, present, and future taking on the "despair" that was equal to the hope the girls received for their wishes.

I need to watch these last two a second time a lot needs to be studied

It doesn't have anything to do with timing.

Time is meaningless to Madoka now because when she made the wish she went to all times and destroyed all witches the moment before they were going to be born. So although it might look like Madoka is showing up to individually put down these witches she actually did all of that the moment she made her wish.

[vernanonix]

Originally Posted by Kenikki

Right, Madoka absorbed all the grief from all the mahou shoujos who had turned to witches and then blew up that entire collection. But the mahou shoujos didn't live on, they disappeared, not even leaving a body behind.

That first girl was "saved" in the sense that she didn't get turned into a witch, but she did disappear.

I think it might be possible that the fallen Magical Girls go to a special place, a sort of heaven where Madoka is. Like when she was there with Sayaka at the end, talking with her. They weren't visible to anyone else and Madoka left with Sayaka. So I think it's possible the Magical Girls live on outside of the normal realm of space and time.

[MugiwaraMarius]

^ Well that would be the cutest heaven ever.

[Verified]

Originally Posted by Kenikki

Right, Madoka absorbed all the grief from all the mahou shoujos who had turned to witches and then blew up that entire collection. But the mahou shoujos didn't live on, they disappeared, not even leaving a body behind.

That first girl was "saved" in the sense that she didn't get turned into a witch, but she did disappear.

...I don't think I quite get what you're trying to say... because Mami, Kyouko, and Homura were all still Magical girls after Madoka's wish. Are you saying all magical girls disappeared, because Homura is definitely going HARD on some demons born from normal human despair working with Kyubei who no longer devours little girl's dreams

@Marius2000 ....errr what dude?

Originally Posted by Verified

I dunno, that first girl that is saved, her soul gem looked like it was about to go witch. And unless Madoka has the best timing ever, that girl was in the past and had already turned into a witch. Madoka obliterated all witches from the past, present, and future taking on the "despair" that was equal to the hope the girls received for their wishes.

Time still holds meaning, in fact it was because of time creating alternate realities that Madoka was able to make that wish Plus, as I said, Homura is a demon bounty hunter now with Kyubei who collects the considerable less energy he gets to still improve the entropy of the universe in order to keep the march of time going.

[Kenikki]

Originally Posted by Verified

...I don't think I quite get what you're trying to say... because Mami, Kyouko, and Homura were all still Magical girls after Madoka's wish. Are you saying all magical girls disappeared, because Homura is definitely going HARD on some demons born from normal human despair working with Kyubei who no longer devours little girl's dreams

All the magical girls who had turned into witches disappeared.

Which is why Sayaka disappeared. Mami and Kyouko, who died while fighting witches, did not disappear.

And Homura never died nor turned into a witch, so she's obviously still there as well.

[MugiwaraMarius]

Originally Posted by Verified

...I don't think I quite get what you're trying to say... because Mami, Kyouko, and Homura were all still Magical girls after Madoka's wish. Are you saying all magical girls disappeared, because Homura is definitely going HARD on some demons born from normal human despair working with Kyubei who no longer devours little girl's dreams

@Marius2000 ....errr what dude?

Time still holds meaning, in fact it was because of time creating alternate realities that Madoka was able to make that wish Plus, as I said, Homura is a demon bounty hunter now with Kyubei who collects the considerable less energy he gets to still improve the entropy of the universe in order to keep the march of time going.

No, time has no meaning to Madoka now she exists outside of time. She even says so. Obviously time still has meaning to everyone else. It's just when it comes to Madoka and what she's doing now time is meaningless.

[thepgo]

Rarely live performances of anime songs are on par with studio recordings - but this one is really good
YouTube - Magia

[oninosweeney]

Originally Posted by Marius2000

^ Well that would be the cutest heaven ever.

... and that is where you get the 99 virgins in Islam. that's one mystery solved.

(man was that joke in bad taste.......... sometimes i even disturb myself)

[MugiwaraMarius]

Originally Posted by oninosweeney

... and that is where you get the 99 virgins in Islam. that's one mystery solved.

(man was that joke in bad taste.......... sometimes i even disturb myself)

Yes it was, but I approve.