Site redesign: What would you like changed in the reviews section? Discuss

Originally Posted by sothis

well it already is set up like that :)

but, if people want to write a more flowing review without sections, it wouldn't work to have it set up like it is now..

oh, well.. see, I never wrote a review before on this site so I didn't know >_>

Originally Posted by DistMan

Another idea could be like with anidb where you have a small 1/10 scale where you grade aniamtion, story characters etc then you write freely (content+summary)

I actually like that ideal

[Crysla]

heya so-chan :)

i'd very much like to see a TV/OAV/Movie designator with each of the review titles. so if you are like me, and looking for a TV series (because i want a nice long anime to enjoy) i don't have to check out 5 oav titles before finding a TV series...

[firebirdV]

(Kinda missed that whole anirec part, sorry), but I do have a suggestion. I don't like being diverted to a URL not found page when there isn't a review and I click on the reviews link.

[HellaSueV]

about what you said Sothis on the other thread about adding Manga recs along with music and such, I think thats a great idea because with manga and music I have lots to say about those especially the music ^^

[LeCKeY]

The currenty issues i see with the system on the out side :).

• Form based submission
• Per-series/review comments
• Peer ratings?
• Better multi review handeling

A form for submission of the review would be sweet i would model it after a mozilla bug report.

Expand the current format and think of the attributes invovled.

• Anime Name
• Reviewer Name
• Story_rating / Story_text
• Visual_rating / Visual_text
• Audio_rating / Audio_text
• Characters_rating / Characters_text
• Overall_rating / Overall_text (This should be some composit score then that is another thing to make you unique )

Comments/notes per the review would be nice the back side to this is spam/flame/bullshit. I figure this should be handled by some tie in with forum?

Raitings again suffer from comments/notes could just turn to crap if you did keep a peer ratings i suggest keeping track and then apply an average to the reviewer :)

the current listing needs update :) i would suggest some sweet tree expanding or maybe some Accordian like example were if you clicked on the name it will expand out to the multi reviews.

And in the backend i would heavly suggest an admin pannel for approval of the submissions to mark them partial or not and general extra admin stuff all around like a edit or delete.

I am having alot of post thought about this you should just create a blank template for the series if there is nothing infact you should do that will all potential series you want in the system and for those have a submission button :)

if storage is the issue with SS that is the only thing that should hold you back :)

thickbox rox -> http://codylindley.com/Javascript/25...-rule-them-all

[Lizard1972]

Well Done Sothis, keep up the good work. I lurk behind you whatever you decide to do. :)