Comment on the list of the member above you

[AkitoKinomoto]

Since this site has lists as one of its main features, I think having a thread made for people commenting on the lists of others would do some good. I haven't seen a thread like this around here, or the forum games section.

Of course, the commenting part would have this thread avoid being better suited for the forum game section. Basically, take a look at the ratings and express your feelings on the person's opinion. So 1/10. Awful taste won't cut it. If stringing together a few sentences is too much to ask, then forget about it.

Now seeing as how there's no user above me, I'm left blank here so I'll just leave it up to the next user, if anyone shows up (whoever you are, feel free to look at the explanation on my scores if they seem too low).

And finally, don't be a boob. Good communication makes all the difference between having a differing perspective and being an obnoxious troll. Remember: opinions are likes asses; everyone has one, but nobody wants to admit that theirs stinks. Basically, show respect.

[SadisticTendencies]

Just looked through your list and, while you've seen several shows/movies that I haven't I disagree with you on the ones we've both seen. You gave Haibane Renmei a flawless 5 which is understandable, and you've given Spirited Away a positive score as well.
I personally wouldn't rate Clannad After Story so high, but that's just me.

Furthermore you've given many of my absolute favorites a 3/5 rating, but that's just a matter of taste. I cannot express in words how much I love your Death Note 3.5 rating; that's exactly what I'd give it and it's not an overrating.

So, to sum it up; you seem to be fair in your ratings although I personally disagree with you on numerous occasions. You've only rated two Anime 5/5 which is refreshing; most people seem to have at least 10^^

[randomredneck]

Lot of stuff on your list thing there, that i haven't seen. Heard of some them, haven't seen them though. And see a couple i won't watch too. Found it rather interesting that you have Dragonball and DBZ as "Won't watch".

Clicked that compare list thing, and saw what we shared. Got the exact same star ratings on like, 4 shows. And how have you not watched Cowboy Bebop yet? Its been out for over a decade. Jeez.

In closing, you got pretty good taste in anime.

[Raitii]

1st - Lots of animes, some i saw others dont , but interesting, he have 11 animes with full rating.

2nd - I didnt read any of his manga, but some i had heard about it in a good way .

3rd - His custom lists is about recommendations and its a nice one.

[randomredneck]

...No offense, but can i go again, maybe get a comment from someone with a proper grasp of english?

[chii]

Raitii Seen 26 anime that I haven't

that's generally all I care about when I compare lists as everyones tastes differs and i can see why anyone would hate or love an anime. (lol @ people who freak out over that stuff)

You should totally make more lists. The 2 you got are interesting but lists are really fun to look at so make the max! :)

[SadisticTendencies]

You commented on my list, so here's my opinion on yours!

I like the high scores for Mnemosyne and Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica, and I'll fall in love with anyone who doesn't give Death Note 5 out of 5, so congratulations on that one. Furthermore, you've given Highschool Of The Dead the exact same rating as I have, and your insulting grade towards Eiken is admirable and understandable. The only ones I disagree with are Black Butler and Blood+, but then again it's still a matter of taste. In short, I'd say that you have a great taste in Anime as well!

And for the record; I hate myself for not having seen Cowboy Bebop. As soon as my wallet recovers from Revolutionary Girl Utena, Boogiepop Phantom and Noein I shall give it a watch!

Edit: I didn't see chii's comment, so this was aimed at "randomredneck". As if I've seen something that chii hasn't ^^

[chii]

there's actually 2 anime you have seen that I haven't SadisticTendencies! :D

[SadisticTendencies]

Originally Posted by chii

there's actually 2 anime you have seen that I haven't SadisticTendencies! :D

Oh my! There should be a badge for having seen 10 Anime that you haven't :)

[chii]

most people have at least seen 10 anime that i haven't unless their lists are veryyyy small hehe.