Sword Art Online

[roriconfan]

Originally Posted by Aranneas

Looks like you're almost right - just the one mention that I can find. I guess my perception was overly coloured in this instance.

Did you tried the review section? Of any site?
Also, it's hardly doing a good job for what it's all about, so it currently gets 1.5/5 for me so far.

[Viduus]

I don't generally rate anything until I'm done watching it, whether or not it's over.

[Pidjiken]

I have it at a 5/5 as well, because it's realistic. This shit actually happens in mmo's, the characters are spot on in their roles and it just fits. It most resembles Ragnarok Online and most Kmmorpg's like it.

[Aranneas]

Originally Posted by roriconfan

Did you tried the review section? Of any site?
Also, it's hardly doing a good job for what it's all about, so it currently gets 1.5/5 for me so far.

That would be what my perception was coloured by. We were discussing the ongoing discussion in this thread. Thus, my remark was off base.

* Honestly, this entire turn of discussion ('y u no rate x') is not what I was trying to spark. Regardless of my intentions I'm not doing much good in this thread atm. Signing off for now :/

[randomredneck]

I don't rate unless I finish or drop. And I don't see myself dropping this anytime soon.

[Verified]

I haven't given it a rating yet, but so far it looks to be on the higher end for me :) I have thoroughly enjoyed the whole season and everyone who has hated on any of the episodes so far, you're just as guilty as the people who "rate it" before its done :P You don't know the impact or significance of an episode until the whole series is done.

ie: Madoka ep 1 & 2 don't really do much for you until you've seen the whole thing.

[Reat]

It's a 2/5 for me right now - but this is pretty far from my preferred genres so I'm sure someone who is a fan will enjoy it more.

[Pidjiken]

Originally Posted by Verified

I haven't given it a rating yet, but so far it looks to be on the higher end for me :) I have thoroughly enjoyed the whole season and everyone who has hated on any of the episodes so far, you're just as guilty as the people who "rate it" before its done :P You don't know the impact or significance of an episode until the whole series is done.

ie: Madoka ep 1 & 2 don't really do much for you until you've seen the whole thing.

I update my rating on an episode to episode basis. This way what I end up with in the end lets me reflect on the entire series.

[thepgo]

Its about 4-4,5 for me. It is kinda selective with what it shows, but I do like what was shown, it gives out a MMO feeling really well, does manage to give 'the big thing' feeling, and is still one of those which when next episode come out, I want to immiedately dl and watch, not leaving it for later.
And on top of everything, It simply gives me ~20mins of solid entertainment. enough for me.

Originally Posted by sothis

i'm going to see if there's a selective forum mod that replaces certain words from certain users with other words. in this case, i'd replace 'harem' with something to do with a broken record or beating a dead horse, for roricon

this post made my day, lulz ;D

[Reila]

3/5 stars here, I'm surprised with the low and lack of ratins people are sayin, considerin how it's got a pretty high rank