Accel World

[Reat]

Originally Posted by greyweather

I went ahead and looked up the manga.

Manga chapter 8 / Episode 5

-snip-

Why would you label that as current episode, when it clearly is a manga spoiler?

[greyweather]

I labeled it as both because it spoils both.

[Rastamepas]

Originally Posted by Reat

Why would you label that as current episode, when it clearly is a manga spoiler?

comparison of episodes to chapters is not considered a manga spoiler. People making such retarded points since the whole another/mirai nikki thread cleaning. Hell ill even explain another rule cause this can land in this area also. If soneone asks to be spoiled it's allowed although it "should" be done via pm directing to the person who requested spoilers. Greyweather imo did not break any rules.

[Nihatclodra]

Greyweather is correct in his spoiler.

They managed to have the same percentage of health, so it ended in a tie.

[Reat]

Why can't you guys get it? If it spoils the anime via information from the manga, it's not allowed. Comparisons are okay, but you can't call it a comparison if it's something that hasn't happened in the anime yet! Pid wrote this in the Sankarea thread:

Originally Posted by Pidjiken

Speculation is fine as long as your knowledge of the series doesn't extend past the most recently aired episode of the series.

If you're ahead and reading the manga your speculation should be in the manga thread, and not the anime thread.

If someone asks to be spoiled, PM them or take it to the manga thread. It doesn't belong in the anime thread. Sure, what was spoiled was small and will most likely be explained immediately in the next episode... but I and many others here don't want to be spoiled, at all, ever.

[Viduus]

What is so effing hard about just not mentioning manga at all in these threads? Instead of just skirting about the damn rules, how about you just don't do it at all?

[Rastamepas]

Originally Posted by Reat

Why can't you guys get it? If it spoils the anime via information from the manga, it's not allowed. Comparisons are okay, but you can't call it a comparison if it's something that hasn't happened in the anime yet! Pid wrote this in the Sankarea thread:



If someone asks to be spoiled, PM them or take it to the manga thread. It doesn't belong in the anime thread. Sure, what was spoiled was small and will most likely be explained immediately in the next episode... but I and many others here don't want to be spoiled, at all, ever.

If its not explained in the anime then its being clarified and thus not spoiled. I was the person that brought the another/mirai nikki/sankarea threads to pidjikens attention so dont lump me with.the whole why you dont guys get it.

If you're going to bawl your eyes out over someone explaining a hole in the episode then please do it elsewhere. Plus it's not even a.spoiler if you werent blind as fuck its not hard to notice

that their life bars were the same at the end

[Nihatclodra]

1) This counts as comparing the latest episode to the EXACT SAME PART of the manga. We are only mentioning something the anime omitted, so it's not spoiling any future events, foreshaddowing, or anything of the like.
2) Unless I am remembering wrong: we were told that answering someone's question about the manga was allowed.

[Reat]

Guys, you can't count it as omitted when it hasn't been given time to occur in the anime yet! Something omitted would be something that could have already happened in the manga but didn't in the anime, like when the manga readers explained more details about the car crash. That's something that was omitted. Explaining who won the match when the fight isn't over yet in the anime does NOT count as something omitted!

Nihat, Pid very clearly explained that any and all manga discussion belong in the manga thread, no exceptions. You can discuss the manga in reference to the anime as long as it doesn't spoil any details of the anime, but you can't talk about the manga exclusively.

Here's more Pid quotes from the Sankarea thread:

Originally Posted by Pidjiken

You cannot discuss the Manga in anime threads. Period. It does not matter how many spoiler tags you place, having a full blown discussion about the latest chapters means it's in the wrong thread, and let's also face it, people have a tendency to just click spoiler tags. This is the anime thread, not the manga thread, future events from the series should not be revealed here or discussed. There are exceptions, but not when it's currently airing.

Originally Posted by Pidjiken

Anything involving future events in the series that has NOT aired yet is NOT to be discussed or posted in this thread. There are a total of THREE and only THREE exceptions to this that I can think of offhand, and I will restate them.

1. When a user actually asks for information pertaining to the manga.

This is when you use the Manga spoilers tag and be very careful to not reveal more than what they have actually asked for. If it's heavy into the plot you might want to post it in the Manga thread and link them to the post from the anime thread as people do have a tendency to click spoiler tags without thinking and then bitch later.

2. When a user requests to be spoiled.

Oddly enough this actually does happen. In this instance you should direct them to the manga thread for their answer as this is obviously plot heavy.

3. Comparisons between Current/Aired Episodes and Manga chapters.

This happens frequently. This one is the most minor of all three as it's basically just what the anime or manga did differently in the episode that already aired. This rarely needs to be spoiler tagged as the episode had already aired, but if the manga difference actually links into the plot somehow it may be used later in the series... You never really know. This happens a lot in the One Piece threads.

Spoiling how a fight ends is
A. Something that hasn't happened in the anime yet,
B. Pertaining to the plot, and
C. Rude.

[Naga]

Episode - 1

Emm I just feel like I swallowed a bucket full of crap. A lot of random stuff, but I like it. PVP arena at the end... just lolz. Reminded me how irritating that pop outs are online gaming. I also can t make myself to like a ugly charachter, god damit.