Anime-Planet's Weekly Manga Club - proposal and discussion

[Nomadicwriter]

woo Im in, i'll pretty much read anything except for probably yaoi and yuri... never have before but i might try... eventually...one day lol

[Omurqi]

I'll participate in the Josei track.

[wolfdv]

Well I'm done reading the first week's material...Aside from 3d Material I found all of them to be pretty good. I'll finish my posts in the discussion threads later tonight...

[TheOmnipotentLemur]

Ill tentatively join up, I think. Sounds fun. ^^

[Omurqi]

Ill catch up with these titles this weekend, but only having access to internet on school this midweek, I won't be able to read before then.

[SlaserX]

Any chance of getting a guy-friendly track?
I love josei as much as the next guy... but I like swords, and explosions, and stories stretched so thin you can forsee the next year's worth of stories, and charging up, and floaty rocks.
Anyone up for it? :D

[Drahken]

I love josei as much as the next guy...

So.... not at all then? :p

but I like swords

Read that katana one, it's all about swords, and it really isn't josei at all. (The only reason I can see for the josei tag is if it was published in a josei mag and/or done by a josei authoer/artist.)

[Otaku108]

Originally Posted by SlaserX

I love josei as much as the next guy...

Originally Posted by Drahken

So.... not at all then? :p

so.... what, does that make me a chick? :P

@ sothis, recommend you set a section up in the General Manga Discussions forum for past track discussion threads so it's easy for newcomers and interested parties to look them over.

[Drahken]

Hey soth, since you skipped 3 weeks, I decided to take the initiative & propose my own list for the upcoming week. This will be a seinen track. Here are the series I propose:

Itoshi no Kana/My Lovely Ghost Kana (2vol/12ch) (it's hard to tell where vols start/end with this series, so I'm including a chapter count too)
AD Police (1 vol)
Baka to Boing (1vol)
Kiss-x-Sis (2 or 4vol) (2 volumes for the club, 4 if you feel like it)
Daphne in the BrilliantBlue (1vol)


Anyone object to this being the list for the week ending nov 12th?

[Drahken]

Looks like no one has any interest in this manga club anymore.