7/14-7/21 Selection & Discussion (for 3+MC/AP200, SPOILERS)

[Otaku108]

The next poll and discussions topic I'm setting up now. As before I would like everyone to PM me their votes.

The Three Month Club (The A-P 200)

Rose of Versailles (40 eps)
Kemonozume (13 eps)
Stellvia of the Universe (26 eps)
Shinigami no Ballad (6 eps)
Ghost Hound (22 eps)

[Otaku108]

Originally Posted by seasong

Rose of Versailles.

Originally Posted by -chii-

Shinigami no Ballad

Originally Posted by Escaflowne

shinigami no ballad

Originally Posted by chamomille

rose of versailles

Originally Posted by KiraRin

Kemonozume

Originally Posted by letsbuildafire

shinigami no ballad

Well, this weeks was yet another disappointment for the Rose of Versalles voters... and yet this is the 3rd week in a row that it's going to carry over to the next poll... wondering if I should make some kind of rule about consecutive 2nd place finishers. Your thoughts on it would be greatly appreciated. I'm going to vote for Kemonozume for it to carry over as well.

Shinigami no Ballad 3
Rose of Versailles 2
Kemonozume 2

[KiraRin]

Great, an emofest week....

Poor Kemonozume >., Guess what I'll be voting for (again) next week...

H.

[ForgottenSon]

Looks more Gothic than "Emo". I'm just glad Rose of Versailles didn't win, not because I don't want to see it, but because watching 40 episodes in one week is a pretty tall order.

[Otaku108]

Originally Posted by ForgottenSon

Looks more Gothic than "Emo". I'm just glad Rose of Versailles didn't win, not because I don't want to see it, but because watching 40 episodes in one week is a pretty tall order.

I would increase the dead line to two weeks for something of that size. Not many people have as little life as I do so I can't expect them to see a series that large in so short a time frame.

[shortlex]

SHOCKS, my vote didn't get counted, I sent my vote otaku and you didn't read it.. grr
I voted for Kemonozume...
I demand a revote

[seasong]

Shinigami no Ballad is not really gothic or emo. It's a rather poetic, short series about life and death. I can't say that it's the best show ever but it's not what you're thinking it is.

[sothis]

i have the same feelings as forgottenson - there's no chance in hell i could watch 40 episodes in one week. but frankly, 26 is too much as well.

shinigami i voted for because it's only 6 and that's definitely doable.

perhaps there should be two clubs, one for "hardcore" and one for normal. the "normal" group deals firmly with anime that are 14 episodes or below (including movies), while the "hardcore" group deals with 26+ episode series.

[Otaku108]

Originally Posted by sothis

i have the same feelings as forgottenson - there's no chance in hell i could watch 40 episodes in one week. but frankly, 26 is too much as well.

shinigami i voted for because it's only 6 and that's definitely doable.

perhaps there should be two clubs, one for "hardcore" and one for normal. the "normal" group deals firmly with anime that are 14 episodes or below (including movies), while the "hardcore" group deals with 26+ episode series.

I'm getting complaints about clutter and really this one club is a bit thin on members as it is.

Being a test pilot for this I think the whole club needs reworking. Mostly need to remove the whole 3month/200 titles requirement and just call it the Anime Viewers Club.

Originally Posted by short_lex

SHOCKS, my vote didn't get counted, I sent my vote otaku and you didn't read it.. grr
I voted for Kemonozume...
I demand a revote

my apologies shorty... I swear I didn't see your vote in my PM in box so if you voted over IRC that's where the draw back for voting that way comes in. I don't have it there to prove it. I'm just going to require everyone that wants to vote to do it over the Forums PM system until a better way is handed to me.

If you did send me a PM over the Forums I have no idea how I missed it... might have accidentally deleted it but I seriously doubt it. Either way I was originally going to vote for Shinigami no Ballad but it had already won so I used my vote to insure the survival of Kemonozume. If you want a recount the only change is Shinigami would go up by 1.

If anyone dislikes that I hold my vote until everything is tallied I will post my vote at the very beginning from now on. I just don't want to influence other's votes is all.

[chamomille]

..so that's why you don't want to vote for Rose of versailles..i know that 40 ep. is too much, it's obvious that it requires more than one week..but if Otaku108 agrees, there's no problem..
i really want to watch it, so i already started dling it even if it never wins..

Chii, you also voted for Rose of Versailles last time..