[TO DO] Site Reviews functionality

[sothis]

Feature List
---------------------
1. Allow users to mark site reviews as favorites


Description
---------------------
This is a placeholder for various reviews functionality

[Ajna]

[Pardon me for noticing late this smal corner of forum]

I'm not sure if this the right place to ask, I guess that a wikified version of the reviews would surely help a lot in making them more and more precise and error-free...

[sothis]

i'm not sure what wiki reviews would accomplish... personally if i was a writer i'd be very offended if a ton of random people started editing my stuff to sound like whatever they wanted it to be.

not sure if you mean "synopsis" when you say review

[Ajna]

Mh, right... I was calling it "review" as a whole (if you have better screens or feel offended by few, you should be able to change them too)...

I guess that little editing is not an issue, btw one can still roll it back or decide to lock his/her review, just in case...

The problem is that I found some error and had no idea about how to report them...

[sothis]

well let's get the terminology right, because "review" refers to an anime review :) "i liked the story, characters, etc" such as in the reviews section of the site.

what you are talking about is the anirec entries (synopsis, screenshots, etc). we will have a system for v3 where you can submit change requests, though we will not allow community changes to be live immediately - they will need to pass through moderation.

[Ajna]

Mh, that's fine enough to me, sorry for misinterpreting the term...

Marking reviewers as favourite would be possible?

[desterion]

That sounds best to have on each page a Report Error/Request Change button.

[VivisQueen]

Thought I'd put it here maybe for V3.1

Would love to have 'average rating' for any particular site reviewer. In fact, depending on cost-returns calculation, might be worth having that for every member, really. But I'd love to know the average rating for my reviews and I think maybe others would be interested to see it as well. (Maybe site reviewers would be interested in donating to such a feature?)

Thanks!

EDIT: Sorry, apparently did not make myself clear. For example, in my profile, it will calculate all the ratings I've given in reviews and give me an average. So anyone who visits my profile can see what my average rating is for all the anime I've rated in reviews.

However, technically, this could be extended to every member. Where I could visit any member's profile and see the average rating they've given for all the anime they've rated.