And there isn't a reason to fight between the two reviewers
, their thoughts and remarks can be retraced rationally and make it easy therefore to understand why they rated Shigurui the way they did (OT, is this sentence understandable?). And disgusted they were both, and myself is no exception. Does someone remember the scene where the big guy had some remarks about the orders of his master?. Holy shit! And to think that they didn't animate (fortunately?) the most disturbing scene of them all from the manga!
You saw 'Samurai Rebellion'? Great movie, starts out somewhat slow but then hits you hard (in the positive sense). Have you seen 'The River Fuefuki' too? It is even better...