Yumeiro Patissiere embraces every shoujo cliché in the book- A clumsy yet hardworking girl with a quaint dream arrives at an ornate boarding school in the middle of a forest. She encounters prodigies, "princely" boys whose every blink and smile are accompanied by sparkles and roses, jealous Queen Bees, and fairies. It's a near carbon-copy of every shoujo series out there, which is fine if you're accustomed to tripe.
To its credit, the series eschews the trap of becoming a simple fluffy wish-fulfillment shoujo. Instead of granting her magical baking powers, thus dooming the show to atrocity instead of merely mediocrity, the sweets spirits give Ichigo extra tutoring sessions. Despite this, Ichigo still masters techniques a bit too quickly. I would prefer a show where the protagonist just mans up and accomplishes her goal on her own, but the light dusting of magical realism isn't too onerous, all considered.
The rest of the plot is less palatable. The Cake Grand Prix, an Iron Chef-esque baking showdown, occupies almost the entirety of the series' run. Episode after episode that could have been spent on character development, comedy, or a variety of drama is instead relegated to Ichigo and team having yet another baking showdown against even more "impossible" odds. A few contests would be admissible, even welcomed, but to devote such a majority of time to them seems merely a way to disguise filler as something relevant.
Even the lackluster plot would be slightly admissible were it accompanied by a shred of believability. Fans of the genre may have no trouble ignoring all the happy coincidences that Ichigo runs abreast of, but the rest of us will have to buff up our suspension of disbelief to accept some of them. When the main characters' specialties are fruits, chocolate, cake, and Asian fusion, of course the upcoming competition just happens to center around those ingredients. And despite the school's claims of being a meritocracy, where students are grouped as determined by their relative baking skill, the teacher arbitrarily places Ichigo in the highest-level group without attempting to assess her skill level. Needless to say, the three ultra-handsome/talented/sophisticated "Sweets Princes" of the school occupy said group.
No expense was taken in making this series look fantastic. Episodes are full of still-frames, blandly-animated movements, and oftentimes only the characters' hair provides clues as to who they are. This is a blessing in disguise, however, as had the animation been better I would have been constantly craving the sweets featured in each episode. For this, my waistline is thankful.
Everything about the visuals augments the series' bland cute factor. Each character sports an abnormally large head replete with almost equally-huge eyes, and the cast and scenery alike are decorated with a washed-out palette of pastels and copious amounts of sparkles.
With a fluffy and unsubstantial opening track, and a score to match, Yumeiro Patissiere's music staunchly refuses to be memorable.
If only the vocal work was so forgettable. The high-pitched chirpy voices of the cast sound like they were recorded in a vat of helium. Caramel's voice actor is the most egregious example- I'd swear she stuffed her mouth with cottonballs (or perhaps Novocaine) before recording.
The lead character Ichigo is such a stereotypical shoujo protagonist that it hurts. She's clumsy, scatterbrained, terrible at math, French, baking, and pretty much every other subject the school teaches. Luckily for her, everyone finds her klutziness "refreshing" and loves her anyway because she's adorable, optimistic, and always tries her best. In a word, she's boring.
Speaking of shoujo clichés- you know the "Prince of the School" that every shoujo series has? Yumeiro Patissiere has three. Between the tsundere boy, reserved gentleman, and overly-exaggerated fop, every single preteen girl in the show's target demographic can find a suitor worthy of fawning over. Were I twelve, I'd be all woozy with hormones over this selection, but armed with few other personality traits, the "Sweets Princes" will have difficulty endearing themselves to a more seasoned audience.
Furthermore, the fairies who serve as the series mascots never rise above being a cloyingly cutesy gimmick. While these type of characters rarely get any development, the show does make attempts at fleshing out the Fairy World yet fails to pay its inhabitants equal courtesy, making them feel especially half-baked. It's impossible to ignore glaring inadequacy in characterization when both the main and tacked-on secondary casts are so vapid and vexing.
Yumeiro Patissiere is cute, inoffensive, and wholly generic. By no means the worst shoujo title available, it is still a far cry from the pinnacle of the genre. It makes decent marathon fodder, as it requires precisely zero thinking, but is otherwise hard to recommend.
The series will appeal to those looking for a guidebook in shoujo clichés, or material for a case study in the ridiculous things that little girls think are sophisticated. Everyone else over the age of thirteen (mental or physical) would do well to steer clear.
Story: Prior to watching this, I had only ever read one cooking manga- Kitchen Princess (Which was absolutely stunning) so I was slightly worried that this anime would look slightly bad in comparison. My worries were proved valid.
The first few episodes of this show did indeed remind me a lot of Kitchen Princess, I had high hopes for this series. But then after about episode 5 ALL THE WAY to episode 50 almost all of the stories were filler, filler, filler. I have NEVER seen so many fillers in a series all my life. Even the actual story seemed like filler, since it is so simple, predictable and pointless. Amano Ichigo has various cooking tournaments against different cooks of different ranks. And guess what? She wins EVERY SINGLE TOURNAMENT. I did not find this very thought-provoking at all.
I really cannot believe how great this seemed in the first 3 or so episodes, and how unbelieably simple it resulted in being.
Animation: For a 2009 anime, the art looks like something from 2003. The art was not very inspirational, it was not that appealing and looked very low-budget. Sure, it could have been worse. But older anime series like Tokyo Mew Mew or Negima?! looked loads better than Yumeiro Patissiere.
Sound: I only finished watching this show a few days ago, yet the music I struggle to remember. It was not that great. The opening song I have to say I hated, I found it very odd, cheesy and embarrassing to listen to. Other songs were bearable, but blended in and failed to add to the mood for me.
Characters: Amano is like any other Shoujo protagonist out there- clumsy, awkward, yet when she gets inspired she can practically rule the world. For Amano, although this did not annoy me, it didn't exactly make me LIKE her either.
The Sweet Princes were alright, their individual personalities were brought out, yet nothing in terms of romance developed in ANY of them. I found that really irritating.
Overall: I am dissappointed. It really showed promise at first, but its just filler upon filler of endless drab. If you're a young girl who loves cooking and can't tell filler apart from crucial storyline, then this is for you. But otherwise, I would advise against Yumeiro Patissiere for the time being I'm afraid.
Before I get down to it, I feel like I need to ask a question of my fellow reviewers. How exactly is this criticised as being "mostly filler"? I may have misunderstood something, but the story of this anime centers around a girl and her friends fulfilling their dreams of becoming patissiers, right? Can we really complain then when the second half of the anime devotes itself mostly to a competition that brings the characters closer to that goal? Especially when there are fan-favorite ongoing anime like Naruto Shippuden out there that stop every five minutes to do ten episodes of filler because they're waiting for the manga to catch up?
Now does all of this mean the YP is good? No. Not even close.
Story: Yumeiro Patissere's biggest flaw is that it's just bland. Bland and repetitive. The story is ripe with cliche, but to its credit, it does tell its rather simple story with heart and sincerity. I think with this anime, you really need to take the target audience into consideration. That being said, it sometimes took risks with the story that, while not always fleshed out, relieved it from being totally monotonous. I cut it some slack, because for what it is, YP DOES at least make the characters work for their happy ending. Some of the outcomes of the episodes later on made me give the series the side-eye (Seriously, is it just me or did Team Ichigo break the record for most ties ever in an anime?) but I personally never felt that things went TOO easy for them. The romance might be a little too played down for some shoujo fans, but I actually prefer it this way, as you see the other relationships between characters built up more.
Animation: Mediocre at best. The art does shine where the various foods and desserts are shown, but not enough to boost my rating beyond anything other than average.
Sound: I never rate this when I critique anime, because aside from the voicing - which is entirely personal preference - I don't much care about it. There were times when Ichigo's voice was too shrill and off-putting for my tastes. I feel like the seiyuu overplayed her crying scenes especially.
Characters: Amano Ichigo is about as boring and cliche as shoujo heroines get, unless you count how many times she screws over her teammates from being self-absorbed, clumsy, or gluttinous. Seriously, I haven't seen a character let their stomach rule them like this since Miaka from Fushigi Yugi (it gets just as annoying). The Sweets Princes are a little more interesting, but none of them stray too far from their initial one-dimensional portrayal. The fairies add a touch of whimsy to the plot, but otherwise don't do much other than look cute.
Overall: If you're just looking to kill some time, like I was, you should be at least mildly entertained by this anime. Don't go into it with high expectations, and you should like it fine.
Story: Very original, very touching, very beautiful. Yumeiro Patissiere is one of the anime with the most emotion put into it. The story develops as the episodes pile one after another and in the end you just can't wait for the conclusion but in the same time are afraid of it and the end of everything. Speaking of emotion, this anime really had me experiencing all kinds of feelings as I continued watching, stopping and continuing watching again. Following the young girl protagonist facing hardships right from the begining and slowly turning every foe into a friend has been shown incredibly picturesque and colourful. The dream of success, the fear of the new enviroment, the rejection, pain and broken will, rebirth of the will to fight and steep falls all over again, all this is shown as a process of growing up not only the main character, but also all characters in the series and even the watcher through their example.
Animation: Although the story has captured my heart, I can't say the same for the animation. Rough motion and plain colours made me really disatisfied almost as much as the story made me awe. However, I must say that the animation gets slightly better when the series reaches its climax and more work is done to the background animation and fatial expressions.
Sound: ...is almost the same as animation. A big minus are the opening and the ending which stay the same throughout the whole 50 episodes (although the ending slightly changes the visual, the song stays the same, and the opening doesn't change at all). The background music is well suited to the scenes being shown, but the palette of the songs is still too small for my taste, and they're not noticable much, although very sweet and when they get stuck in your head, they really get stuck in your head!^^
Characters: Many. many, many of them, and all different. If you're not good with names, you'll get in trouble here. A big plus is that every character that has been selected out of the croud has been carefully developed (with the exception of the adults), main characters more than the supporting, but that's what you'd expect, right? The special accent is made on the main four, the protagonist and her team, and all the others have been completed as much as the plot requiered it to (that means they're rich as a character as long as you don't go into the past, where there's a big hole). The focus is made on the development and growing up in the present, with the exception of the main protagonist, whose past has been detaily explaned (because her late grandmother is highly significant to the plot, so through her past we got to know her grandmother as a character). There are also a lot of family ties, especially in the main character's family and her team members'.
Overall: The accent has been made on the concept of growing up and the will to suceed in life while chasing your dream. Regarding that, I'd say it's a very enjoyable anime to watch when something isn't going as smooth as exepted. If you watch it when everything is OK in your life, it will perhaps turn out a little boring. All in all, a very educational anime and suited for all ages, just like a classical children's story: you can repeat it in different times of your life and it always reminds you of what's important. ^-^
Even though I really enjoyed this anime, there is certainly lots of room for improvement. I think most of the show's mistakes can be overlooked, the severe lack of storyline really can kill it for some people. I found that during some points I had to force myself to continue watching simply because of the lack of excitement. Everything else like I said was either good or not bad enough for it to be a major problem. I personally really enjoyed this show however, and would suggest it to most shouju fans. And, if you want romance, you should afterwards watch the professional version.