These anime are both reverse harems with plenty of colorful male characters interacting with the female main. The school setting makes them more similar and they follow the same format of having episodes dedicated almost exclusively to one of the boys. Fans of one will probably enjoy the other.
Both are reverse-harem disasters! If you are into cliched and cheesy reverse harems then go ahead watch the other one as the core of the stories are similar.
After being stood up during a date on Christmas Eve, Junichi’s confidence took a critical nosedive. Two years later, he’s now a second year high school student and ready to give love another chance. Will he fall for the beautiful and popular Morishima, mischievous childhood friend Kaoru, shy and timid underclassman Sae, dependable class president Tsukasa, hardworking underclassman Ai or his gluttonous childhood friend Rihoko? Only time will tell, but one thing’s for sure: Junichi is determined to make his next Christmas Eve date a successful one!
both Amagami SS and Starry☆Sky are the story of the main character getting with a multitude of many other characters. The stories a short, simple and feel-good. However in Starry☆Sky the main character is female, and in Amagami SS the main character is male, if you can get over this both series are a great watch
Tohru Honda is a compassionate girl who is down on her luck. Her mother having recently died, she has been forced to camp out in the woods for shelter. However, things start to turn around once she is invited to live with class hunk Yuki Sohma and his family... but all is not as it seems! Yuki's family is burdened with a dark curse which causes them to turn into the animals of the Chinese zodiac once hugged by a member of the opposite sex... and Honda may be the only one who can help them.
An urban legend tells of a Miracle Train that runs the tracks of Tokyo’s subways. Appearing only to troubled ladies, it’s said to house a few young men who are manifestations of the Oedo Line’s stations; together, they are able to solve any problem that plagues their passengers. Whether it’s helping a girl who lost her dog to a woman who refuses to tell the boys of her problems, Shinjuku, Roppongi, Shiodome, Tsukushima, Ryogoku and Tocho-mae will help anyone they meet aboard the Miracle Train.
Yay for bishies! While Miracles Train has each station personified as a person, Starry Sky similarly personifies each Zodiac constellation as a person.
Both series structure each episodes to be somewhat of a standalone but with plenty of plot and amusement.