If you're looking for anime similar to Shuffle!, you might like these titles. All recommendations are made by Anime-Planet users like you!
Yukinari is blessed with an clinical fear of women, commonly known as gynophobia. In addition to his mental ailment, he has the misfortune of being short and weak, making it easy for women to overwhelm him further. Even when his childhood friend, Kirie, approaches him, he immediately breaks out in hives. Thus, life is very lonely for Yukinari, until suddenly in the strangest way possible, he is transported into another world, and into the arms of the beautiful shoujo, Miharu! This time, for the first time ever, he doesn't react. Could this be the start of something special?
Both Girls Bravo and Shuffle have one boy and a pack of girls, and lots of ecchi humour -- it's what makes them good! Shuffle maybe has more drama, but that's ok.
These animes are really similar.
Rin gets to chose from girls that are outta this world! One comes from the demon world and the other from the god world. The only difference is Rin is not awkward and all of the boys are envious of him. This harem is funny.
Yukinari on the other hand is puny and is allergic to girls. He too finds a girl that is from another world and guess what? He is not allergic to her. The adventures they have are soo funny. It fact this is a harem because a lot of girls like Nari despite his condition. There is also an obnoxious perv that adds to the fun.
One day, after a visit to his parents' grave, Teppei Arima spies a damsel in distress, and nobly saves her from a gang of thugs. Relieved and grateful, she introduces herself as Princess Charlotte Hazelrink. Thinking nothing more of this, Teppei soon receives a surprise call from his grandfather, informing him that he is the heir to the Arima business empire and therefore one of the richest men on the planet! Teppei is introduced to his personal maid, Yuu, and various blue-bloods, among them his arranged fiancee, Sylvia - a fencer with a tongue as sharp as her blade. At school the next day, Teppei meets more new faces, including the snooty Seika Houjouin, and - much to his surprise - Princess Charlotte Hazelrink. Still awkward and uncouth, Teppei must somehow adjust to high society. With girls pursuing him at every turn, however, that may be the least of his concerns...
Well, there shouldn't be much further explanation required. Both Princess Lover! and Shuffle! are largely set in a school, both are about a guy pursued by several nubile young ladies and both promise a heaping helping of ecchi humour. Although Shuffle! featured nudity and a storyline, while Princess Lover!'s story is mostly absent and it doesn't yet appear as though anyone's going to get their tits out, they're still similar enough to pair up like this. Also, both titles end with an exclamation mark.
Both titles have male main characters who could more or less have his choice of several different women. A classic theme behind a harem as to which both of these are. Both animes feature compeling storylines that is used throughtout most of the episodes for some fun and enjoyment and to simply build on the characters and the relationships between the main character and the other women. Also towards the end of each series they add just enough drama that will make you want to see it through to the end.
Hiroyuki Fujita's only distinguishing trait appears to be his perpetual laziness... but he has something about him that lets him make friends with girls easily, and has a kind side that his childhood friend Akari loves. Follow their 'everyday adventures' in high school with this light schoolkid comedy.
For Aizawa Yuuichi, returning to the town where he spent his childhood has been an unusual affair. Yuuichi, it seems, has forgotten his memories of the past, including encounters with several young ladies who would love nothing more than to see him again. As the days pass, flickers of the past began to surface, revealing more and more of the dark events that once came to be. As the reuniting continues, Yuuichi soon starts to realize that his past may be far more complex than he once believed it to be...
Kanon is similar to Shuffle! because they are both based on the choice of the lead male charecter. Kanon offers less if any ecchi (if you count big well hidden breasts under sweaters ecchi) and has little comedy. It is more romantic and emotional story. Its not exactly like Shuffle! but it is similar in many aspects.
Guided by a star only they can see, a group of maidens known as HiMEs have begun to gather at Fuuka Academy. These young women have been endowed with dangerous supernatural powers that they can use to their heart's content, but there's a price: to wield them, they must put their most important thing on the line. Now, in the midst of school work and friendships, they find themselves caught in the midst of strange conspiracies seemingly related to the terrifying monsters that attack them. Is the power of the HiMEs strong enough to save themselves and the ones they love?
This recommendation is a bit unusual, read on at your own risk only :-) SPOILER AHEAD: ------------------------------------------- The thing that connects Mai Hime and Shuffle is the development of the story, and the fact that after 2/3 of the series, the seemingly comedial and lighthearted story is turned upside down and the rest becomes much more interesting and darker. For this reason I can recommend both - keep watching even if you found the beginning of the series to be uninteresting, yet funny.