If you're looking for anime similar to Rosario to Vampire, you might like these titles. All recommendations are made by Anime-Planet users like you!
Maya Kumashiro is an uptight teenager who has returned to the Waldstein “Occult Academy” following her father’s death to assume his role as principal. With a hatred of the supernatural, she initially intends to run the school into the ground, but her plans are thrown into chaos when a new teacher, Minoru Abe, descends from the sky. Claiming to be a time agent, Abe informs Maya that he has been sent from the future to prevent the Nostradamus prophecies from coming to pass. With a rift to another dimension due to open at the Waldstein Academy that will lead to aliens conquering the earth, the unlikely pair must locate a mysterious object known as the Nostradamus Key and destroy it before humanity falls prey to the occult once and for all.
Throughout the ages, fairy doctors served as liaisons between humans and fairies; but in the present time of the 19th century, fairies are nothing more than an old wives' tale. Nineteen-year-old Lydia Carlton is one of the only remaining fairy doctors and enjoys a quiet life in the countryside of England - that is, until the dashing Edgar, for mysterious reasons, whisks her away on a daring adventure. Said to be the descendent of the earl of the fairy nation, Edgar desires the noble sword of the merrow that serves as proof to his lineage. Though his motives and origins are questionable, Lydia now sets forth to help Edgar on his quest.
Kodaka is a delinquent. At least, that’s what his fellow classmates seem to think. Thanks to his naturally-blonde hair and an unfortunate series of misunderstandings, the boy can’t seem to shake his false reputation and hasn’t made a single friend. That is, until one day he overhears the normally-aloof Yozora enthusiastically chatting with an imaginary friend, and discovers that she’s just as lonely as he is! In an attempt to finally meet people the duo decides to form the “Neighbors Club”, and are soon joined by a number of other fellow misfits such as Sena, the busty, popular daughter of the school president who can’t seem to connect with others. Together, the gang learns about the joys of friendship through many misadventures such as playing RPGs, visiting the swimming pool or even hunting down delicious takoyaki!
Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai reminds me a lot of Rosario to Vampire in the sense that the male protagonist is in search of friends in a new school. Both shows are centered around school life and full of comedic moments, but Rosario to Vampire focuses more on action and romance than Boku wa Tomodachi ga Sukunai does. You can expect otaku references, laugh-out-loud moments, ecchi scenes, and even tons of moe in both shows as the male protagonists tries to live out a normal everyday school life.
Manaka Junpei is an average guy who has only two dreams in life: to become a filmmaker and to find the girl of his dreams. Luckily for him, after a chance encounter on the roof of the school, he has a lead on the girl! She was wearing strawberry panties. Unfortunately, he can't figure out which one of the five girls chasing him it was; but he gets plenty of chances to find out the color-of-the-day in his Cinderella search for his one true love!
Both are well executed high school harem comedies with the male leading being a lot more likeable and less perverse than most. Ichigo is more realistic and dramatic, while Rosario is more supernatural and comedic. Ichigo is the superior show by far, but if you found one entertaining, the other will probably satisfy as well.
Ten-year-old genius Chiyo, animal-loving Sakaki, loudmouth Tomo, athletic Kagura, weight-conscious Yomi and dim-witted Osaka are six friends who share laughs, good times, and a high school homeroom. With scary (and sometimes perverted) teachers, school festivals, penguin suits and general hilarity abounding, you can be sure that there's never a dull day in the life of one of these students!
Why these two when Rosario is clearly more ecchi than Azumanga? Well, because Azumanga parodies the ecchi school girl anime (see Kimura for reference), and because both of these animes are a lot of fun. While Rosario has a bit more fighting and drama, Azumanga is not without its share of hilarious action. School trips, girl geniuses, and mentions of breat-size float between these two animes.