This is a list I pulled from skimming my watched anime at a glance. I just picked the ones that stood out too me as exceptional / above average anime. They are in no particular order except for the top 4 for some reason are some of my favorites...
Favorite Anime. (Unordered List)
All anime i've watched so far (updated evry 4 months)
The top fifteen are my favorites the rest have no particular order.
Romantic animes with a touch of supernatural.
you can also find mystery anime here.
Watch out for school days, don't watch it too young, you have been warned