If you liked the Pretear anime, the Anime-Planet community thinks you'd like:
After successfully defeating the X-characters, Amu and her friends are back! However, as everyone except Yaya is set to graduate at the end of the year, their team will soon split up. Luckily, Chairman Tsukasa appears with good news: a new student is to be inducted into the Guardians. Curious as to who the new addition will be, the gang meets new transfer student Rikka Hiiragi, who surprises the group with news that she can both see and understand their Charas, but has none of her own. The Shugo Charas are filled with bubbling excitement with the prospect of a new friend, but will the new girl be able to keep them out of mischief, especially as the mini personalities are now allowed adventures of their own?
Both Shugo Chara Party! and Pretear, feature magical girl as a main tag. In both animes we start with girls who possess weird personalities and are unaware of their powers. If you like one of this two shows then you will definitely like the other one as well.
they both have masou shojo as you know but the have some of the same struggles with becomeing who they are and also in devolping there powers
Momomiya Ichigo was a normal girl, worried mostly about her crush, Aoyama Masaya. However, just as she was finally able to date him, she was struck by a mysterious beam and everything changed. She is now part of the Mew Project, genetically fused with an endangered species of cat. With her new powers and companions, she must protect the earth from invading aliens.
both are about groups of people fighting "bad" forces. even if the "bad" forces may not be completely "bad". tokyo mew mew is about a group of grils fighting and involves a little (or a lot depending on how you look at it) of romance, as does pretear. even though pretear is about a group of (optional: hot) guys and tokyo mew mew is cute girls.
Both series have the whole mahou shoujo/tansfomation theme going for them, and they both involve a young girl who suddenly finds herself using her powers to save the world from some kind of evil. Both are similar enough in their feel in that if you enjoy one, you'll probably enjoy the other as well.
Angelique is the queen of the cosmos in a lush fantasy world, with nine strong and handsome guardians at her command. What started as a simple reunion between friends turned into a nightmare when the recently deceased Arios came back from the dead with a sinister plan to kill both queens! Can the gang come together to save not only themselves, but Arios himself?
Both Pretear and Angelique center around a normal girl who's suddenly thrown into the middle of a handful of loyal and amazingly good-looking guys, all while taking the role of the "savior of the earth" of the planet they're thrown into.
Chances are that if you're a fan of one, you'd like the other.
One afternoon on her way home from school, Haru saves a cat from getting run over by a truck and promptly gets the shock of her life when it stands on its hind legs to thank her. That night, she is greeted by a parade of felines who inform Haru that her earlier heroics saved the prince of the Cat Kingdom. Haru suddenly finds herself inundated with gifts of mice and catnip as means of thanks, culminating in the announcement that she will be taken to their kingdom to marry the prince. With no desire to marry Prince Lune, Haru turns to The Baron and Muta from the Cat Bureau for help, but unable to stop them, Haru is swept away by a horde of cats. Can Haru prevent this marriage of inconvenience and return home before she becomes a cat herself?
Both anime feature teenage heroines searching for their identity and place in the world. Also, both feature strong fairytale themes--Pretear is (very loosely) based on Snow White, whereas The Cat Returns is an original story that has a lot of typical fairytale trappings. Although Pretear gets a little darker in tone towards the ending, both have warm, hopeful, lighthearted tones. I have a strong feeling you'll enjoy one if you liked the other.
Throughout the ages, fairy doctors served as liaisons between humans and fairies; but in the present time of the 19th century, fairies are nothing more than an old wives' tale. Nineteen-year-old Lydia Carlton is one of the only remaining fairy doctors and enjoys a quiet life in the countryside of England - that is, until the dashing Edgar, for mysterious reasons, whisks her away on a daring adventure. Said to be the descendent of the earl of the fairy nation, Edgar desires the noble sword of the merrow that serves as proof to his lineage. Though his motives and origins are questionable, Lydia now sets forth to help Edgar on his quest.
They both have strong main female characters. While Himeno is more teenaged & goofy, & Lydia is more adult & sure of herself; they both have one thing in common. They both have a man behind them, the men want to protect & love these women.
In Hayate's case, he's just too chicken to tell Himeno how he feels. Edgar is the opposite, he will do whatever it takes to make Lydia love him back.
They're both lovely & they are both enchanting stories.