If you're looking for anime similar to Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha, you might like these titles. All recommendations are made by Anime-Planet users like you!
Hinamori Amu is a stylish punk rock girl who is liked and feared by her peers, but there's just one problem: she's actually a shy and quiet girl who can't seem to drop her self-fabricated facade! But when Amu finds three eggs in her bed, she had no idea her life would change forever. Out of the eggs pop Ran, Miki and Su, Amu's Guardian Charas; these being represent parts of Amu that she wishes she could be, even allowing Amu to transform into those parts at will! Now, with pressure from the other Guardians (including her crush, Hotori) to join their midst, dark sides of the psyche known as X Eggs to seal, and nefarious forces after a wish-granting egg known as the embryo, Amu's life has officially become more complicated!
Much like the first season of 'Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha', 'Shugo Chara!' offers an unabashed magical girl-adventure with flashy transformations, endearing characters, and a protagonist who fills the hearts of all those around her with love and happiness.
I do want to point out that I find Amu (the protagonist of 'Shugo Chara') a lot more interesting and fun than Nanoha, seeing as she's pretty spunky and not annoyingly polite and perfect all the time.
Both series have female protagonists who suddenly become "magically able".
Nanoha operates on a larger scale then SC, and is faster paced. Still, if you liked one, check out the other.
Both anime are about magical girl's and there enimies become in both anime there best friends. If you liked 1 you will live the other.
When a strange samurai tells her she is the successor of the swordsman Yagyu Jubei, Jiyu Nanohana refuses to believe him. But the descendants of Jubei's rivals have already sensed this, and one assassin after another is sent to attack Jiyu! Fortunately, Jubei left a little something for our heroine - a lovely heart-shaped eyepatch. As soon as Jiyu dons the eyepatch, she is overcome with Jubei's power and transforms into a ninja girl! Jiyu must put an end to the 300-year old feud between the samurai clans... before the feud puts an end to her.
Jubei-chan and Lyrical Nanoha are recognized for their magical girl stylings: an unwilling female protagonist, the wise sidekick who guides her as she takes her first steps into a larger world, and a mystical artifact that's the source of the heroine's power.
But instead of being targeted to the usual demographic, these two shows seem designed for male audiences. Both series feature enough action to keep viewers interested and provide the necessary back-story for enjoying their respective sequels.
Jubei-chan and Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha are clearly both magical girl series. However, they are both unusual in that they aren't necessarily aimed at a female audience, as are most magical girl series. In addition, they both have superb action sequences and a protagonist who manages to reach out to many of her foes and show them the error of their ways.
Awayuki Himeno is a normal schoolgirl who is in a bind: her father’s remarriage yielded two new cruel stepsisters, and to top it off, she meets seven men who call themselves Liefe Knights. They reveal to her that she's a Pretear, someone who can lend powers to them when their powers aren’t enough to defeat the evil creatures called mayouchuu. Now, she has to fight the ambitious Fenrir, whose only purpose is to leech the life force from all living beings. Can Himeno save the world and find a way to deal with her growing feelings for one of the Liefe Knights?
Other than the fact that Pretear has a group of guys as magical support instead of a cute animal these animes are alike in many ways. Pretear is geared toward a slightly older audience, however. If you like a girl beating magical creatures up then you may like Pretear.
Both anime are about girls who find out by acicent that they have magical powers. Both have anemies who are in the end not so bad and even become friends. If you liked the other you won't regret if you watch the other.
Life can be tough when you're a teenager. Enter Tsukino Usagi, an average, if somewhat clumsy, junior high student whose voracious appetite for sweets and capacity for tears are offset by her enthusiasm for life. Her normal existence is suddenly turned upside down when a talking cat named Luna comes into her life. Suddenly, Usagi finds herself with the ability to transform into the superhero known as Sailor Moon. Fighting the occasional monster may be the least of her worries, though...
Both Sailor Moon and Nanoha are magical girl series. Both of these series follow the young girls as they discover their power. adjust to a new - and more dangerous - life and begin their quests. While Sailor Moon has a more comedic and monster-of-the-week feel to it, and the two protagoists have completely different personalities, if you liked one, it's worth trying the other.
Girl finds small, injured animal. Girl decides to take care of animal. Animal turns girl into monster fighting magical girl! In order to defeat the big bad, the girl must find the crystals that can be triggered by human emotions. The girl eventually gains allies in her fights, and eventually confronts the big bad.
I think I just summed up both the original series of Sailor Moon and Nanoha. So, if you liked those aspects of one, don't worry, you'll find them in the other.
Illya loves magical girls; but more than anything, she loves her brother and wishes he would pay more attention to her. So when a talking magical wand appears, offering her a chance to make her dreams a reality, it seems too good to be true and she hesitates. But unfortunately, her touch was the only consent needed, and now Illya is stuck as a magical girl! On the bright side, she has all the powers that go with the job – like magic beams, shields, and incredible cuteness! But her path to love is a dangerous one, as she must now capture powerful and magical items known as Class Cards, while keeping them out of the hands of rival magical girls, before her wish will be granted.
Both involve seemingly normal elementry school girls through random chance gaining the ability to use magic, having to collect certain dangerous items, etc. They also both have intelligent magical devices that help them along the way.
Both shows are also spin offs which veered into the magical girl genre, while their prequels were of a much different setting. Such as the main characters not being the main characters of their parent shows, very different plots, etc, save for the fact that magic existed in the Fate/Stay night and Zero realms but Triangle Heart had no magical characters.
So if your a fan of shows with magical girls, magic, or even their parent/spin offs. It'll be worth your time to atleast check it out.
Let's begin with the obvious; Both are magical girl spin-offs of very non-magical girl shows.
Other than that, both have a similar dynamic of a solo magical girl with a solo dark magical girl rival, who try to collect some magical items. Both shows further mix light-hearted elements with mostly physical action. The main objective of both heroines is obtaining several objects of magical power, as well as to befriend the other magical girl in the series. Furthermore, in neither show does the main character have an initial interest in becoming an magical girl other than wanting to help out.
If you like one you should try the other.