There are many individuals online who seem to believe that all anime, regardless of its genre or general quality, is art. According to them, each and every series is something to be admired from a suitably safe distance, and any sort of criticism is basically heresy.
The problem with this theory lies in shows like Hana Yori Dango. The show seems interested in nothing but catering to the lowest common denominator, and throws all manner of clichés into the work to do so. If Hana Yori Dango is "art," so is fast food.
The shows derivative nature is most noticeable in the plot, which seems to be moving on rails from the very start. Even those with minimal experience in either traditional shoujo or Hollywood romantic comedy will still probably find the "twists" predictable and the by-the-book dialogue all too familiar. Everything feels hackneyed and overdone. In one scene, a character shouts out that he loves the protagonist, but his voice is drowned out by a noisy vehicle that happens to be driving by at the time. Seriously, who hasn’t seen that somewhere else?
Despite this, the plot is initially entertaining on camp value alone. The cheesy and predictable nature of the plot lends a certain charm similar to what Fushigi Yuugi had going for it. However, this isn’t really enough to carry the series for all 51 episodes; it’s only a matter of time before the gas runs dry and the show tanks.
All of this leads to an ending that is at once obvious and moronically illogical. The contortions that the writing has to go through in order to twist the ending into something acceptable to the studio execs surpass mere deus ex machina and into absolute absurdity. The anime doesn’t quite dip to the level of the “it was all a dream” style of conclusion, but comes far closer than any respectable work ever should.
The series is also hurt somewhat by its age; the animation was most likely only serviceable when the show was aired, and has since aged horribly. In particular, the character designs feel extremely dated and ugly, and any sort of action looks clunky and unnatural.
For the soundtrack, practically the entirety is comprised of classical music mixed at a fairly high (and noticeable) volume. This might have actually worked better in a classier show, but when played alongside the soap opera antics that the characters engage in, the music feels distinctly out of place. The music also becomes a little repetitive when the same handful of tracks is used for all 51 episodes.
Such a story has been saved in the past by a set of solid, likeable characters, but Hana Yori Dango has no such luck. The protagonist has the perky, survive-through-any-hardship vibe that seems to be a universal trait among shoujo heroines, but is otherwise a blank slate (similar to male “heroes” in harem shows). The two main love interests fare slightly better in originality, but I hated them all the same. One character is a violent, stupid and snobbish oaf that will probably be beating his wife in 20 years, while the other shows so little emotion that it’s difficult to feel anything for him at all. The two personalities seem as if they were made specifically to appeal to shallow female adolescents, most likely because they were. The supporting cast ranges from mildly annoying to completely forgettable.
As a whole, whatever charm the series might initially have in the beginning is lost as the longwinded, predictable and dull plot drags out the premise to the point of tedium. The technical elements are lackluster, and the characters are sub-par. Like other "classic" romance anime from the 80s and 90s, the show will never be forgotten by its fans, but probably should be.
Story: Putting it simply, the story of HanDan is very simple and just like every other romantic shoujo comedy out there- but theres a reason why they are a all like this: Because HanDan managed to pull it off with such success that the others all followed suit. From the first episode of the series, I could tell it would be an emotional, magical story what would pull me in and amaze me, and it did. Easily my second favourite anime of all time (It would be first, if not for the fact that Digimon was my first ever anime hence my top favourite) Hana Yori Dango boasts great characters, great gradual storyline-what may have sometimes dragged- but was still pure genius, and superb at everything.
Animation: I'd wanted to watch this series for a long time, but the art style had put me off as it really wasn't to my tastes and since the show was older than I was I immediately presumed I wouldn't become much of a fan of this show anyway-how wrong I was. Within about 3 or 4 episodes I was used to the animation and old style of it, and by about episode 15 I was in LOVE with the animation- I wish there were more shows with that style of animation in fact. It could be a little slobby at times, but in general it was very good and got better as the episodes progressed.
Sound: Sad to say, music isn't the strong point of this particular anime, but hey, we don't watch anime for the music after all. The opening sequence I ALWAYS skipped as soon as I got to episode 2 or 3- I just HATED it. It sounded like it was from the 60s and was horribly outdated and cheesy. The music in the actual show was sweet and mostly instrumental with piano and violin accompaniments. They were VERY repetitive to the extent that you knew each song almost off-by-heart but they sounded good and suited the overall mood of the anime, so I can't complain.
Characters: Characters are what make this show sparkle; their all superbly etched out, their individual personalites made clear from minute one, and you end up loving them all from minute one. The love triangle between Tsukushi, Tsukasa and Rui is one of the most memorable ones in history and the greatness of it is that its never clear exactly whom Tsukushi will end up with, not like most Shoujo's where its blindingly obvious and you know exactly how it will end.
Overall: Easily the best Shoujo I've ever watched or read, this is a must-watch, regardless of its age and old animation.
Adapted from the best-selling shoujo manga of all time the Hana Yori Dango anime has big shoes to fill. The initial premise of the show is that Tsukushi Makino comes from a very poor family but attends a school for the wealthy members of high-society. This opens up a sandbox of possibilities for a great mix of school life and drama. So throw in the romantic connection between Tsukushi and the two richest boys in the school and you have an obvious yet clever setup.
The execution is surprisingly rife with cliche. There are contrivances and misunderstandings, the script is full of angst, and many scenes frequently tide over into the arena of melodrama. Yes, these factors are very present but they do not ruin the anime. Hana Yori Dango is exciting and rewarding because of these aspects and believable despite them. And, most importantly, Hana Yori Dango is not trashy. Hana Yori Dango is classy. If you need a lesson in trashy, I would suggest (but not encourage) you to check out Ayashi no Ceres.
Hana Yori Dango progresses in a typical will-they-won't-they style which can understandably become tedious. However, Tsukushi and Tsukasa's journey is highly tumultuous as various secondary characters enter the frame to stir up vindictive amounts of trouble and conflict. Themes such as bullying, jealousy, and class distinction are served up like a hearty full English breakfast in a fairly blunt manner. Tsukushi's life is endangered on a number of occasions and she encounters prejudice and hostility practically everywhere she goes. Hana Yori Dango offers quite the rollercoaster ride with plenty of surprises, it twists and turns and practically every episode leaves you hanging before another sharp drop.
Easily the ugliest show in my list of favourite anime. Character designs are awkward, movement is sometimes mechanical, backgrounds are soft but lack detail. Colours feel particularly watered-down and do not offer much variation, but this actually makes the anime easier on the eye. There is a certain charm that the animation and art style offers, in that very few other anime look anything like this, but it can be jarring until you relax into it. Those who find poor animation an unforgivable factor in anime (an unfortunate majority) will struggle to sit through Hana Yori Dango's 51 episodes. However, once the show is over, and considering you enjoyed it, you won't be able to imagine the show looking any other way.
Hana Yori Dango benefits from a rich classical soundtrack that allows it to retain a sense of timelessness. I can only imagine how much 90s cheese the OST would've had otherwise. The OP and ED hint at what we may have had to endure - the OP sounds like a poor early Beatles imitation but is catchy and enjoyable in its own right. The music of Hana Yori Dango is fairly repetitive yet memorable, though at times it heightens the melodrama to a superfluous level - there is one composition that wouldn't be out of place if played during the climactic battle of man vs. nature in an adaptation of Moby Dick.
What encourages me to give extra points in this category are the voice actors. The entire cast is made up of unknowns, the majority of whom have no credits for any other roles. However, they treat the script with care and for the most part the acting does not feel too cheesy. The dub, however... atrocious. Tsukushi is voiced by Kelly Sheridan who is not suited for strong female types (this is a woman who plays Nana Komatsu and Barbie in the same voice as Shuurei Kou and Tsukushi... err, what?) and Tsukasa's voice-actor may not have understood the character at all since, aside from sounding whiny, he gives off a far more bratty and snobby air than Tsukasa has.
The real star of the show is Tsukasa Domyoji. He is very detestable for a good chunk of the show - an intentional move. Adjective dump: violent, stupid, desperate, aloof, arrogant, irrational, cold, and self-destructive. Tsukasa is difficult to like until you realise that these cracks result from the damage he endured from parents that neglected him and his sudden feelings for Tsukushi that he clearly doesn't know how to deal with. As the anime progresses you begin to see evidence that he has all the aforementioned traits and their opposite inside of him. The Domyoji family is one of the richest in Japan, and while Tsukasa is obviously spoiled by most people's definitions he is not a brat so much as a lonely teenager. Living alone in a mansion the size of a hospital? Complacency and apathy should surely follow. The snobbish comments he makes are spoken with a brazen honesty that sounds like he's merely stating facts and not opinions. He is so far from your typical romance male lead that I was willing to like even his horrible side at the beginning because of how refreshing his character was. For all the shitty things he does his character triumphs through some beautiful moments of redemption.
Tsukushi Makino is the heroine and lead character. Her feisty and determined nature is combined with sensitivity and a frequent lack of reason that gives her character a sense of frustrating realism but also makes her fun to watch. Tsukushi has no problem drop-kicking and punching her way through the story, followed by flurries of panicked thoughts after she is clear of the conflict. Sometimes it is hard to know which part of her is a front and which is genuine, and her simultaneous tendency to make terrible decisions and be blind to the obvious can be frustrating, though luckily she does not sink to the level of downright retardation like characters such as Mitsuki Koyama. She essentially remains the same person throughout the anime, her main development comes in the slow disintegration of the walls she has erected around herself that surprisingly result in her being one of the most closed-minded characters in the show. I do not feel it would be too presumptuous of me to say she probably set the standard for what makes hot-headed and strong-willed shoujo lead females so widely used today. However, given that Hana Yori Dango has slipped somewhat under the radar Tsukushi may not bring anything unique to the table since the concept has been repackaged into much more popular characters such as Skip Beat! lead Kyoko Mogami.
Secondary characters are surprisingly hard to ignore. In-between Sakurako, Junpei and Mrs. Domyoji there are some true villainous characters who display levels of manipulation and hatred which will boil your blood. Rui Hanazawa is Tsukushi's other love interest and I will leave him for your own discovery - and also because a character so difficult to read defies my ability to define him.
Hana Yori Dango has downfalls but enjoying it feels equal to indulging in a rich gateaux which you simply can't regret because it tastes too damn good. I would recommend this one easily to the shoujo, romance, or drama fans. To all others I say: don't let your inner critic take the wheel when watching this anime, just let them sit back and enjoy the ride. It's a classic and has set standards. The story would be refreshing to watch even now after the emergence of so many genre-defining school romances since HYD. It wouldn't surprise me if Hana Yori Dango was pegged for a remake in the next 5 years - watch this space!
Hana Yori Dango is a rather old anime (1996/97), so for starters I guess it's only honest to say that the visuals and animation are quite bad. I didn't much like the voice acting either. It's a typical shoujo anime, a romantic comedy with lots of melodrama, angst and an over-abundance of clichèd scenes and dialogues. What did I think of it? Well, the first couple of episodes are terrible; so much so I was just about to drop it. But I kept going and in the end I watched all of the 51 episodes in two days. So it does get engaging.
The plot is basically a love triangle - one girl and two boys; and I have to admit I'm a sucker for those. Our heroine enrolls in a posh high school that caters to the richest and most powerful of the country because her modest lower-class parents dream of marrying her off to a wealthy guy thus securing the entire family's future. So in the initial episodes you see Tsukushi being mercilessly bullied by her schoolmates because she's the poor girl with no background or social standing - and I was quite put off by this. Most of the bullying in the school originates from the F4, a group of 4 extemely spoilt, arrogant and violent kids who belong to some of the wealthiest families in Japan and who think that their families' money entitles them to trample over and crush anyone who gets in their bad books. Tsukushi - our spirited heroine who isn't about to give in to the bullying without fighting back - clashes with the F4 and declares war on them. As she gets to know them better, the love triangle starts to develop, with Tsukushi falling for one of the guys and another one of them falling for her. And it takes 51 episodes to sort through all of the mess of the characters' feelings and misunderstandings. While there are many annoyingly stupid and repetitive moments and scenes, all in all I don't think the romance is bad. What I did find awful and ridiculous is the ending. It felt rushed - which for an anime 51 episodes long is absurd. But yes, it nearly ruined all of it for me. It's a complete let-down. Apart from the romance and the bullying, a third theme that is dealt with is the social one regarding the discrimination between the upper and lower classes, the rich and the poor. I was surprised by the fact that Tsukushi, who apparently seems so willful and strong and impervious to prejudice, is actually profoundly affected by class differences.
The characters are decent. The main ones have all got their own distinct personality. Most of the anime is about Tsukushi sorting out and admitting her own feelings, so comprehensibly at times she does get a little irritating because the anime often drags and gets repetitive. The boys aren't bad either. Tsukasa starts off as the villain, but when we get a little of the character's backstory he suddenly becomes a lot more likeable. During the unfolding of the story he also does undergo development and change. Hanazawa Rui is also a cool character, but that becomes apparent only towards the end. For most of the anime he is this aloof and mysterious guy you don't exactly know what to make of. The side characters are stereotypes for the most part, some are portrayed better while others make little sense. The comedy is usually entrusted to Tsukushi's parents - who made me laugh out loud more than a couple of times.
In conclusion, I'd recommend this anime to hardcore romance fans. With the caveat though that the ending is really terrible.