On the surface, ef - a tale of memories seems to be your average romance anime series, featuring a range of characters forming relationships as they spiral awkwardly towards adulthood. Certainly, this series almost disappeared under the radar, and I only watched it on the recommendation of a fellow fansubber who was enjoying it himself. And I have to say, I'm glad I did.
While ef - a tale of memories does follow the accepted path of romance series, it's the way it proceeds, dancing away from clichés as it goes, that really makes the series. The plot itself isn't anything particularly sparkling and the idea of duplicity (two separate stories involving a different set of characters playing out alongside each other) certainly isn't new (see: Baccano and, to a lesser extent, Shinigami no Ballad) even if it handles both of these rather well. However, the strong emotional clincher at the beginning of the series, where we learn of Chihiro's shocking condition, grabs the viewer by the heart and refuses to let go. Where this series really hits it mark is in its cast of characters. The characters are ones you can either relate to, or demand sympathy. Ef is as much a series about unrequited and unwelcome love as it is about becoming romantically aware.
The series has a great way of whisking you along with it, whatever the action is. I was gripped from start to finish, awaiting each new episode to be released, which is a rare event these days. Ef's greatest tool is its fantastic storyline and direction, where not a single second is wasted onscreen without invoking some emotion in the audience. What the director has done well in this series that have failed in other similar titles, is maintaining the fine balance between the optimum amounts of action and introversion.
Having said this, however, there are flaws inherent in the ef model of storytelling. The problem I've always found with duplicity is that they only work if the stories are equally as enthralling -- Baccano works despite its massive cast because every character has an interesting story to tell. Ef, however, has a much stronger storyline in the childlike romance of Renji and Chihiro, than the bordering-on-cliché love triangle of Kei-Hiro-Miyako. Unfortunately, when this happens, the viewer is dragged in by the stronger storyline and sees the weaker one as deadweight -- to the point where it feels like that whole half could have been dropped to make the series stronger. This is what I felt for most of the love triangle story, despite liking most of the characters involved and the individual pieces of magic it brought to my computer screen.
This score is a hard one for me. At times, there are some real breakthroughs in anime artwork, in particular the two amazingly emotional scenes where Miyako and Hiro are communicating by phone (or not, in the case of one of them); and at other times, the viewer is left to deal with long distance shots with only small variations in movement.
It's a hard one to judge, but ef definitely receives higher marks for its wonderful scenery. Nearly every backdrop becomes memorable for its richness of colour, and each setting is perfectly realised -- from the beach where Renji talks frankly about his feelings with Chihiro, to the rooftop of the school, the centre of a climactic scene that I've no doubt I'll always have imprinted on the back of my eyelids.
I almost feel harsh for knocking this down a few pegs, but I get the feeling that if the art directors had just pushed the boat out a little bit more on those near-static scenes, this would be a masterpiece that everyone would remember. As it is, it has some fantastic glimpses of what it could have been.
The best soundtrack I've heard in an anime series. The last time I heard two songs so distinctly unusual to an anime series was in Gunslinger Girl, another series with an amazing opening and ending. I think, like Gunslinger Girl, ef can only achieve the emotional heights it does with perfectly placed music. The ending is an astonishingly good song, played on the accordian in what I can only assume is an imitation the sounds of Paris. There's so much going on in these songs that it's a delight on the ears listening to them.
My only comment on the music is that it would have been nice if the opening theme was in Japanese, instead of dodgy English, but even then, the song itself is a wealth of strings and orchestral wizardry -- and with a scrolling animation as beautiful as "Puzzle" was in Welcome to the NHK! to accompany it... well, I can forgive this one minor downside.
As I mentioned earlier, the duplicity of the plot unfortunately doesn't lend itself to the characters it portrays. On the one hand, Renji and Chihiro are two of the strongest lead characters of any romance series I've seen, with enough flaws to fill a psychiatrist's journal (some of the faces Renji pulls are more reminiscent of Higurashi than Love Hina). On the other, we have Hiro who is too wishy washy to really be the centre of a love triangle, and Kei who seemed to fall into too many of the regular romance traps to be taken seriously.
But then, she is the clichéd member of the cast. While other characters have compelling motivations (Hiro's attempt to juggle drawing professional manga and schoolwork, Miyako's desire to find a place where there is no such thing as silence), her only reason for existing is to be the childhood friend who secretly loves the protagonist but remains unnoticed despite her best attempts. Luckily she's strong enough not to fade into obscurity, but her character is weakened from the outset.
I think it's unfortunate that the character that piqued my interest the most received the least screentime. I wanted to see more of Kyosuke and the way he viewed life through his camera lens, forever searching for the "right" angle. I found his perspective more interesting than Hiro, but it seems as though his involvement in the story is only to give Kei another option in her lovelife. Which is disappointing, to say the least.
It's the relationship that sparks up between Renji and Chihiro that carries this mark though. In fact, on the basis of their endearing love story alone, I considered marking this a 9, maybe even a 10, but I couldn't justify it, especially when you consider that the two "teacher" figures in the church are never really introduced, talked about, or even explained.
Before anyone else says it -- yes, I'm aware that ef - a tale of memories does border on the absurd more than once, teetering along the edge of being emotionally charged and being hilariously over-the-top, but all I'll say to that is, if you're willing to let yourself be swept away in a less-than-conventional rollercoaster of a love story (or two) then this is the one for you. Yes, it has its flaws. Yes, half the characters seem either worthless or unused. Yes, it would have made much more sense to have some sort of crossover in the plot somewhere. But frankly I don't care, because this came out in a Fall season where every popular title was disappointing and this shone out above all the rest. Vastly superior to Myself;Yourself which aired at the same time, and perhaps, if given the chance, a romance series that will be seen as a milestone of the genre.
Ef – A Tale of Memories (pronounced ‘eff’) is a short 12 episode drama romance anime, based upon a light novel. I think (couldn’t find in English), but apparently there’s visual novel versions of it. A unique anime, capable of invoking emotion and making the viewer think, something I appreciate. Off the bat, this was a rather serious, yet sensible anime with a mature, intricate plot. I must also add that I’d watched the first episode of this anime many years ago, when I was sampling the first episodes of a variety of anime to see whether they were worth watching later (many years later!). This was one of the ones I looked forward to all this time, I even got vibes of my favourite anime of all time, Angel Beats. I will disclose my dislike for ecchi, harem and shoddy romance, relevant in a later bit.
HOLY MOLY! The quality of the animation felt like it was years ahead of its time. Watching it in no less than 1080p, I felt the quality of animation was comparable to more modern anime such as Another and the aforementioned Angel Beats. On the odd occasion, the framerate had slight noticeable drops, but it reminded me that this was no movie like 5 Centimeters per Second, thus for a 12 episode series, the quality was on point. But the quality wasn’t the only astounding thing about the animation.
The style. The first thing noticed about it is the standard looking character designs, done rather well of course. But the animation style itself is rather unique and stood out a lot. I was reminded of anime with styles like Kare Kano and Neon Genesis Evangelion, just add some random power line shots and there you go! The scene transitions had poetic lines, from what looks like a book, making me all the more sad that this doesn’t have an English light novel. There’s artistic use of grayscale and monochrome, I can vividly remember one scene where the character was drawn in white on a black background. The intro/outro sequences feature similar inventive colour simplification, with characters being depicted in shades of just a single colour. The intro uses just two colours at a time (if one doesn’t count white). One thing that some folks may dislike is the use of silhouettes, especially where the camera is zoomed out and glow around character models. As well as interesting camera angles, I also noticed in one scene the original use of silhouettes and background. The entire scene was black, except for the animated characters, which were actually windows into the background. It’s difficult to explain, imagine if holes, the shape of the characters, were cut out of black paper and was overlaid over a normal image. I love how creative and distinctive the animation style of this anime is.
The last thing to mention is the ‘rated’ aspect of the animation. I’m happy to announce, zero fan-service or ecchi crap. There’s occasional references to stuff, like a guy sitting nude and working at a computer, while his girlfriend sleeps naked in bed, likely after having made love. It’s as it sounds, sensible camera angles and well within context for justification. The closest thing to bs are guys being grabbed from behind, but they never draw attention to it.
One last thing, I’ve seen complaints about the content in other reviews. From the way they were talking about it, it sounded like this anime could be quite vulgar. Don’t be fooled, this anime still maintains prudence, there is no nudity and the adult scenes are dealt with very reasonably. If it wasn’t, then I’d be the one ranting about it and complaining about it, just see my Elfen Lied review. There is a fine line when it comes to depicting this stuff and most anime fail miserably, but this is one of the few that manage it perfectly. The beautiful animation style even continues, it’s still very artistic in the way it is depicted. Don’t let anyone tell you the love scenes are too much, for real ‘too much’ go see an anime like Berserk.
I was disappointed by the first couple of episodes, since it seemed like there wouldn’t be an intro sequence. Thankfully I was proved wrong and this anime also seems to have quite a few outro sequences, each seeming sung by each of the 3 female characters. The intro was is some surprisingly well-sung English, though at times the pacing was off. I felt like the first outro could bring tears to my eyes, it sounded so beautiful. The music from the anime itself, was used suitably. The usual high standard of background music, comedy tunes for the funny bits, serious music for the serious bits and sad stuff for the sad bits. Mostly beautiful instrumentals, like piano. Which is dynamic in the mood, it changes as the scene changes. And of course, some moments had no music at all, which was done purposefully. I felt like the music on its own could portray the atmosphere and emotion, independent of the animation and dialogue. With music so beautiful, I did get the soundtrack though I was still listening through the Shakugan no Shana music collection (12 hours of solid music) from the last anime I watched.
It just so happened that this site didn’t list the English voice actors for the last anime I watched, in the past I’ve been misled to believe that anime are Japanese only because of this. Thankfully, since I watched the first episode many years back I know this is available in both English and Japanese. But once again, Anime-Planet has let me down, no English voice actors listed and some characters are missing. I watched it in English, especially since that’s how I watched the first episode all those years ago, but also since this anime has a good cast of English voice actors, I swear they had the entire cast of Clannad for this. Turns out the English cast voiced characters in many of my favourite anime.
So major folks in the voice acting industry, starting with Greg Ayres as Hiro Hirono, starring in roles including Ayato Naoi in Angel Beats, Koichi Sakakibara in Another, Kouta Tsuchiya in Baka to Test, Youhei Sunohara in Clannad, Keisaku Sato in Shakugan no Shana (last anime I watched) and Kaoru Yamazaki in Welcome to the NHK. Chris Patton does the voice of Kyousuke Tsutsumi, the voice of such characters as Naoya Teshigawara in Another, Greed in FMA and Yuuichi Aizawa in Kanon (2006). Chihiro Shindou is voiced by Monica Rial, who was Misuzu Kamiyo in Air, Mei Misaki in Another, Chane Laforet in Baccano, Hyatt in Excel Saga, Lyra in FMA, Misao Ogami in Kaze no Stigma, Sakura in Tsubasa Chronicle, Hazuki in Tsukuyomi Moon Phase, Maria in Witchblade. Brittney Karbowski voices Kei Shindou, also the voice of Yuri in Angel Beats, Yukari Sakuragi in Another, Ryou Fujibayashi in Clannad, Kiko Kayanuma in Darker than Black and Ayu Tsukimiya from Kanon (2006). Miyako Miyamura is voiced by Luci Christian, having voiced Haruko Kamio in Air, Masami Iwasawa in Angel Beats, Nagisa Furukawa in Clannad, Ophelia in Claymore, Wrath in FMA, Medusa in Soul Eater, Haiji and Hikaru in Tsukuyomi Moon Phase and Hitomi Kashiwa in Welcome to the NHK. Clint Bickham voices Renji Asou, having also voiced Yuuya Mochizuki in Another. Yuu Himura could be recognised as David Matranga, also the voice of Takaki Tohno in 5 Centimeters per second, Mr Kubodera in Another and Tomoya Okazaki in Clannad. Yuko Amamiya’s voice was recognised as Carli Mosier, voice of Akira Yoshii in Baka to Test and Wilhelmina Carmel in Shakugan no Shana (coincidence?). Shuichi Kuze is voiced by Illich Guardiola, the voice of Katsumi Matsunaga in Another, Yusuke Yoshino in Clannad and Masaru Kato in Gantz. Mizuki Hayama is voiced by Hilary Haag, voice of Yui in Angel Beats, Fuko in Clannad and Merry in Dream Eater Merry. I took the liberty in this section, since not even the anime credits list the English VAs. What is this discrimination in this industry?
Probably the most important of the main female characters, 16 year old Chihiro Shindou is the frail and physically broken one of the Shindou twins. She lost her eye, which is why she wears an eyepatch and is unable to attend school because of a far pressing matter. Since four years ago, her ability to retain memories was so severely impaired that she was unable to retain any memories past 13 hours. Thus, she has taken it upon herself to write a diary, which she reads before bed so that she can remember the important things that occur in her day to day life. She aspires to be a writer, but her memory makes this difficult. Over the years, she’s attempted to write her novel dozens of times but to no avail. Due to her disability, she doesn’t attend school and live separately with the rather protective Yuu Himura (treated as an older brother) as her legal guardian. During the course of the plot here, she makes friends with the boy Renji Asou. Personality-wise, she is very shy and gentle, but somewhat strong-willed and will often accuse Renji of being mean.
Hiro Hirono is a 17 year old guy who attends the Otowa highschool (likely in his final year, guessing by age). He is unable to attend school often, due to his full-time work as a professional mangaka (manga artist) drawing shoujo manga (i.e. aimed at girls) under the pen name Nagi Shindou, which allows him to be self-sufficient and live on his own. Despite this, he has never learnt to cook and eats quick food like instant noodles. Being a manga artist is his dream and he puts all the time and effort he can into it, trying to grab every extra opportunity he can. He has even developed tendonitis in his drawing wrist, which sometimes makes it difficult for him to draw. He lacks sleep as a result of staying up all night to draw his manga and meet the deadlines. He means well, but ends up being kinda indecisive and half-arsed at things, trying to juggle a lot at once instead of focusing on what’s important. Still, his true self pulls through. Kyousuke is regarded as his best friend and the Shindou twins are childhood friends, though Kei is much closer. He ends up meeting Miyako Miyamura during the anime and gets caught in a love triangle between her and Kei. He has a pleasant personality, he doesn’t care for much besides following his dream and occasionally helping his friends out when they pester him. He has a key to the roof of school, which is his special place where he likes to be alone.
Miyako Miyamura is the same age as Hiro Hirono and in the same year Otowa highschool. Yet the two have previously never met since she is also a delinquent, rarely attending school. She likes to cook for Hiro, who was put off cooked food by Kei’s cooking. Unlike Kei, Miyako is able to cook well, this might be because she appears to live by herself too. Initially Miyako seems to be a cheery, mischievous girl, often with a smile on her face and dragging Hiro along to do stuff. She often gets upset at him when they are out, leaving him to pay for the bills by himself. Miyako seems to be a character with a lot of freedom, but she feels lost and aimless as a result, she wants to be anchored. She seems to respect what he does and wants to let him draw his manga as he likes, except for spending time with her. But soon we find out a bit more about this girl, especially since a certain phrase aimed at her by Kei cuts deep. There’s a lot more to this character than meets the eye.
Kei Shindou is the other of the Shindou twins. A year below Hiro, she calls him senpai at school (Otowa high) and big-brother (onii-chan) elsewhere. She is athletic and plays basketball, she seems to take good care of herself and thus her body is more average, in comparison to her twin’s frail chassis. As a childhood friend of Kei’s, she was the one who got him into girl’s manga and drawing them. In essence, she was responsible for his dream. But she also harbours feelings for the guy, which she rarely shows him. She is very concerned for his wellbeing, suggesting he put less time into manga and more time into school. She even wakes him up every morning. She’s no deadly chef, but her attempts at cooking are terrible nonetheless, which turns out to be a thing that runs in her family. She goes to her best friend Mizuki for help cooking and such and just to hang out. Kei’s personality is not necessarily as pleasant as the others, she can be aggressive, jealous and rather horrible. But she’s a human being at heart, these flaws are to be expected. She means well towards her friends and Hiro, but she feels guilty about the events four years ago concerning her sister.
Renji Asou is a 16 year-old high-schooler who lives alone with his mother. He seems lost and has no idea what to do with his life, claiming to have no talents or skills in which he is proficient. That is until he meets Chihiro, who brightens his day. He often visits Kuze Shuichi for advice and help. Personality-wise he’s a nice person, much more pleasant than most of the other characters, he’s very gentle with Chihiro, though that doesn’t stop her claiming he’s being mean at times. But soon he finds out about Chihiro’s problem, which makes it difficult for him to get close to her and develop a relationship. Much like Miyako, one must watch the anime to see how complex this character really is. It’s not all bright smiles and sunshine.
Kyousuke Tsutsumi is a friend of Hiro’s, a boy in the same school. At the start he is part of the film club and is dating the film club president. His dream is to shoot a beautiful movie, sparked by his late mother who was an actress, whose acting was so beautiful that he wanted to make something similar. He disagrees with the other members of the film club who want to make something to win prizes, while Kyousuke doesn’t want such things to taint his creativity and ideas. He resigns from the film club and even breaks up with his girlfriend. His opinion on creativity differs to that of Hiro’s. Hiro mentions he’s a bit of a player and thus slightly dangerous for girls to be around, but you soon find he’s a rather caring, pleasant and deep individual. He feels he can see everything through the lens of his camera and his lens is caught by Kei, who he discovers is the film subject he was looking for. He wants to film her as she is and doesn’t want to interfere with her life, letting her do as she would normally do.
Yuu Himura is Chihiro’s guardian an adult whom she considers as her big brother and together they live at a church. His occupation is completely unrelated to his abode, he isn’t a priest or reverend. When asked why he is there, he claims to be waiting for someone. He has Chihiro’s best interests, but also tries help Renji as trying to advise him with what he believes is the best option. He understands how difficult it is for Chihiro and potentially the difficulty one may face when and if they get close to her. This character is somewhat mysterious and he seems to be the closest thing to a father figure for Chihiro, trying his best to prevent her from doing anything to hurt herself, being a tad violent if needs be.
Mizuki Hayama is Kei’s best friend and in the same class/year. Unlike Kei, she can cook very well. Like Kei, she enjoys reading girls manga and is a fan of Nagi Shindou, who she is unaware of as being Hiro. She’s a bit jealous of Hiro, since she seems to have feelings for her best friend. She’s very light hearted and cheery, much like Miyako, but without the ‘other’ side.
Sumire Asou is Renji’s mother, she seems to look and behave a bit too immature for her age. She makes awkward jokes about her son’s love life and even jokingly flirts with him and the neighbour. Speaking of which, Kuze Shuichi is the next door neighbour, a womanizer who also plays violin. He shamelessly flirts with Sumire, being confident enough to mention the awkward stuff with her son. The closest thing to a pervert this anime has, he also seems to have the same hairstyle as Renji. Since Renji’s father is never around, he’s actually the closest. Finally there’s the mysterious woman in the black hat who appears to certain characters to provide advice and disappears like some sort of supernatural being or ghost.
The plot essentially follows three intertwined arcs, each featuring a cast of the 6 main characters. One arc concerns Renji and Chihiro, another is about Hiro, Miyako and Kei, while the final smallest arc focuses on Kyousuke, but mixes in a bit with the second. The plot is here in its full glory, this is no slice of life and I’m happy to say this is a romance narrative taken seriously. It’s unpredictable, at one point I thought it had just gone down the drain after some significant progression. The narrative of this anime is carefully interwoven with the characters, without one you can’t have the other. It’s a human-based story. And it’s not an easy one at that, being rather complicated and dare I say real.
Most of all, this story has a lot to say, not being simple means there’s a lot to read here. I feel like it’s suggesting things about key topics such as life and love. It’s has the potential to invoke emotions in the viewer, I wouldn’t be surprised if folks cried watching this anime. And also to induce thought as I mentioned in the intro, the viewer is trying to figure out what’s going on and the characters are done so well, one could almost empathise with them. It’s a beautiful story and I’d write a lot about the subtext here. But to do so could potentially spoil the story. Some wise words are mentioned by some of the characters. Because pain and suffering exists, it allows us to feel happiness and joy. Love (a fictional concept, check my Romeo and Juliet review for the little rant) is a double-edged sword. One thing repeated by Yuu that also holds true: “There are no such things as miracles in this world. Just the inevitable and accidental. And the things we do. That’s all.” Much of this anime suggests the characters are wandering lost, trying to find the things that matter to them most, to find a dream they can truly strive towards and make them happy. And best of all, the conclusion was magnificent. I couldn’t see it coming from a mile away, but it made a lot of sense and most of all, it put a smile on my face. That said, I’m a person at peace and the small things make me happy, even if fleeting.
Overall it’s a beautiful story, but one that would go unappreciated by younger audiences or those who don’t understand and would cast it off as soppy. Its fine, this anime doesn’t need those kind of people watching it.
Overall I loved this anime, it reminded me of some of my favourite anime ever and I’m wondering if there’s a place for it in my top five. Who would I recommend this anime to? It’s a true romance anime and a beautiful one, much like Kimi ga Nozomu Eien, so I’d definitely recommend it for romance fans. But I’d also recommend it to adults who don’t enjoy typical anime BS, because it’s something that’s different and unique. If the first few episodes don’t reel you in, then don’t bother with it, the best thing to do is to ignore it and move on with your life. Because it’s so complex and unique, some people probably won’t appreciate it. I’m reminded of what I said in my 5 Centimetres per Second review, it’s like a beautiful flower, some people don’t care. But others will see it for its beauty. If you have a good taste in anime, then you’d enjoy this. Personally, it’s anime like these which make me glad I got into anime, it’s unique stories like these that I strive to find within this bogged down (by crap) media form. I’d definitely show it to a friend, especially one who has romance or relationships on their mind (even if they don’t enjoy the genres in media).
Family-friendliness Rating: 5/5 Nothing offensive, but inappropriate for minors nonetheless (lower is better)
Overall Rating: 10/10 (higher is better)
Much like one of the main characters, Chihiro, my only hope after watching this series is that I lose my memory of it in thirteen hours.
Story - 3/10
The meat of the show can be broken up into two stories, each one covering a different complex relationship between a group of high school students.
The first is the much more complicated of the two, with a love triangle (unbeknownst to the male of the group) and a fourth person who is infatuated by one of the other three.
Hiro is a young man who meets Miyako wandering the streets on Christmas Eve. She tells him she lost her keys and no one is home at her house to let her in, so he keeps her company for the night. He later finds out she attends the same school as him, but is renowned for skipping classes, which explains why he’s never seen her before. When the two of them start spending time with each other it brings out the jealousy in his childhood friend Kei, who does her best to take care of Hiro, hoping he’d realize she has feelings for him. The more time Hero and Miyako spend together the worse things get, culminating in Kei threatening Miyako into erasing her from Hiro’s life, which only causes her to deepen her relationship with Hiro.
Making the situation worse is Hiro’s classmate Kyousuke, who decides to start stalking Kei after catching a glimpse of her in his camera’s lens. When she doesn’t agree to date him he asks if he could just follow her with his camera, which essentially leads to him being Kei’s support system in her trying time.
When their story ends it seems as little is resolved with any of the three possible relationships. You get some hints to what might come, but you’re basically forced to watch the second season or use your imagination.
The second road the story takes is that of Renji and Chihiro, a young girl he meets at an abandon train station, starts to like, and then learns has an ailment that causes her to only remember thirteen hours of her life. Determined to help Chihiro, Renji starts to see her every day at the same time, and convinces her to follow her dream of writing a novel, (which oddly seems to be based off the Take on Me music video by Aha) so that she’s never forgotten. Despite her attempts at protecting Renji from having to relive her amnesia day after day, he chooses to stay and struggle along with her.
The Hiro storyline is along the lines of most slice of slice or romance drama anime series. It’s not necessarily bad, it’s just not really there. With only around four hours of actual run time, encompassing two stories, you need to get to the point, truncate stories or really wow us with the writing and plot, but here they decided to skip all of those. While it does take away a little, they could have trimmed down Kyosuke’s story in order to deepen the main plot. Repeatedly jumping back to essentially the same two scenes of their youth also was just wasted frames. This would have been fine as a show of it’s own, but instead was three frame comic strip in the Sunday paper.
While a bit different from many anime’s that came before, the Renji and Chihiro plot line isn’t necessarily groundbreaking. Falling in love only to find out that person is ill is one of the most common tropes in film and TV, pretty much the backbone of the Romantic Drama genre. The emotional aspect feels extremely cheap too, as they don’t put in the work of building up the characters, instead they much drop her ailment on you and cause you to have feelings not so much for the character, but instead for the idea of a child being injured. Her illness is also a convenient way to not have to write much, as they can continuously repeat the same scenarios and scenes over and over, since Chihiro forgets and needs to remember.
Much like the other half of the series, too often the interaction is built around atrocious gal game writing. Instead of having human interactions, you get Chihiro essentially saying “how may I please you master?” or “Thank you so much, shall I reward you with sex?” This all comes to a head with their romantic encounter, which should pretty make anyone’s skin crawl. While the first story wasn’t too bad on this front, between Chihiro constantly referring to Renji as her “lover” and the fact she has the mentality of a twelve year old, this all seems as if it was targeting sexually stunted males who fantasize over little girls and being waited on hand and foot.
I think the person who came up with the original concept had a good idea, but was let down by those actually making the show. Relying was too heavily on gal game plots, dialogue and creepiness doesn’t make for a good piece of art, it makes for, well, let me leave that to your imagination.
Animation - 4/10
While everything in this series Is pretty much on par with the anime of it’s time, i.e great consistent animation with very bold colors, the show runs into problems when it comes to the asthetic choices made in other areas.
The first annoyance, which is shared from the series’ connection to a dating sim, is the frame composition used quiet often throughout the show. Constantly a female character will just pop into a Medium or Three Quarter shot, with no movement, as she reacts to her male counterpart, reminiscent of how these games portray your interactions. It’s somewhat jarring and out of place for an anime, not to mention lazy.
Another interesting, yet somewhat annoying, visual choice is the prismatic backgrounds they overuse. Whenever someone is backlit by water or sky they use a style and filter that at first looks nice, but by episode ten just starts to seem cheesy.
Rounding out my gripes is the character design for heroines in the show. Chihiro, Kei ,Miyako or Yuuko, take away their hair and there’s no telling them apart. They slapped the same exact face on every girl, which works for the twins but not for everyone else. Each male character is unique, but it would seem the lead concept artist had one type of female he was in love with and just repeatedly used that image for his ladies.
This series also includes one of the worst examples of pure laziness that I’ve ever seen in any form of entertainment. In the tenth episode there is a scene that is supposed to cover Ninety-Nine seconds of a phone call. The scene takes four and a half minutes to complete, and the whole time it switches from a still image and a clock counting down. Four and a half minutes of basically two separate frames, used over and over again with terribly written dialogue being spewed out over it. This scene alone almost made me want to rate the show a Zero, because it showed how bad this poor excuse for an advertisement anime was.
Sound - 6/10
The opening theme hits you like a ton of bricks, a loud, screechy ton of bricks. It calms down after the initial chorus, but then lyrically turns into a train wreck, sounding as if they wrote the lyrics in Japanese, translated them to English for the song, and completely ignored the timing and sync.
The ending themes were much more interesting than the opening. The first one, I’m Here, is a bit out of place, feeling more like it should be in a European set show, but still is a very well composed and performed piece of music. Like the first ending, Kizamu Kisetsu, sounds out of place, with it’s bad eighties hair metal guitar, but still is a decent tune in the world that is anime themes.
The rest of the music is what you expect in anime, cookie cutter orchestral pieces, composed of the same eight loops you’ve heard over and over again.
The voices in the English cast are, like the music, exactly what you thought it would be. Greg Ayres, Chris Patton and Clint Bickham for the guys, and Luci Christian, Brittney Karbowski and Monica Rial for the girls, pretty much the same people in every single Sentai licensed series. Now the voices aren’t bad, well except Chihiro which is your typical soft spoken almost to the point of brain damaged young girl, but I’m just getting a bit tired of hearing the same half dozen V.O. artists in every single series, if you’re going to hire the same people over and over they should at least have the ability to do multiple voices, otherwise it’s just bad casting.
Characters - 3/10
While I’m sure the writers saw their creations as deep characters with great backstories, to me they mostly came off as poorly conceived and executed with cheap tricks to make it seems as if there was more than meets the eye. This is one of the few series where I can honestly say I hated pretty much all the characters, and I watched Final Fantasy Unlimited.
First lets start with the males, since it would seem despite being a romance title, this is actually a series targeting the male audience. The main male, Hiro, is probably the least terrible of the bunch. He’s actually a decent character as a whole, driven to pursue his career as a manga artist. He seems to be the only character not playing a game, but rather being a normal person. If this was a series just about him I don’t think it would be that bad.
Tied to Hiro is his classmate Kyousuke, who can best be described as a pompous turd who think’s he’s an artist. He’s a “filmmaker” who gets angry and runs away from his club when he’s informed that his garbage style (randomly filming things and thinking that it’s so artsy) is about as entertaining as the anime he’s part of. When he catches a glimpse of Kei through his lens he dumps his girlfriend and asks Hiro to introduce them. He spends the rest of the series creepily following her with his camera (again not actually making any type of art, just getting random shots that would be useless even in a documentary) and trying to be her white knight, when in reality he hasn’t a clue what’s going on and barely even knows her.
The third of our male leads in Renji, a nice guy who happens to fall into a strange situation. He meets Chihiro and doesn’t know her situation, but as a standup guy he sticks around and tries to better her life. Although he does mean well, things kinda get a wee bit rapey when you think about it (he sleeps with a girl that loses her memory after thirteen hours and is in the perpetual mindset of a twelve year old, sure it’d legally be on the up and up, but still a bit icky)
The female characters a essentially written to be overly flawed love interest who pine and fight over the males of the series.
Kei is a psychotically obsessive girl who wants to control every aspect of Hiro’s life. From a young age she had a crush on Hiro, but more like that of a sibling who thinks their older brother or sister is the greatest. Despite the desire to be the center of Hiro’s life leading to tragedy, Kei never learns from her mistakes, and she continues to bully him into living the life she’s created for him. Her almost violent reaction to Miyako spending time with Hiro would pretty much chase any male away, and did.
As for Miyako, she first comes across as a strong female, but it’s later revealed she has abandonment issues due to her parent’s relationship with each other (a relationship that is basically described in almost the exact same way as Nanako’s parents in GTO’s pilot episode) This all comes to a head when Hiro misses their planned meeting and she leaves him a hundred crazy voice male messages. After finally reconnecting with Hiro, and getting him to choose her over Kei, she decides to leave him, showing how she’s pretty much just as crazy as Kei.
The last of our three female leads is Chihiro, Kei’s twin sister who is permanently injured when she’s hit by a car. Now she’s stuck continuously regressing back to the age she was when she was hit, only being able to remember a thirteen hour time period before her memory starts to vanish. She tries her hardest to remember Renji by writing about him in her journal and repeating memories of him in her head, but in the end she tries to take the easy way out by ripping up her journal and staying away from Renji till her memories subside. Like Miyako she decided to only care about herself and not worry how she hurts the person who loves her and has tried to be there for her. The most annoying part about Chihiro, and possibly the entire show in general, is how they make Chihiro act not as a twelve year old, but almost like a three year old, crying and saying everything is “So mean” to pretty mundane things.
Along with these six main characters are a few throw away people who would basically be the NPC’s that tell you the princess is in a different castle or where to find the witch that guards the secret helm of destiny. Some of these character’s include Renji’s almost incestuous mother and their overly sexual neighbor. Mizuki, who they tried to write as a girl in love with Kei, but instead received ten seconds of show time. Chihiro’s caretaker Yuu, who we’re not sure if it’s really her older brother or just some weirdo who decided to take care of her, despite her family living five minutes away. And Yuko, a woman who may be a ghost, but may be a dead lover of You, but who we never really find out about, because why would you give information or backstory on characters? Doing that would just screw up the whole “random sack of garbage” anime they created.
Overall the characters can be lumped in four small groups, idiot males, crazy pathetic females, random useless characters and Hiro Hirono. I don’t know what the aim of the writers were for these characters, as their lack of redeeming qualities and overall terribleness isn’t something anyone would be looking for in a significant other.
Overall - 2/10
The series really came across as nothing more than fan service to people who enjoy dating sim games where girls swoon and fight over the player character, making him feel loved and adored.
The story is intentionally broken up into many different parts because no single section has much to it, except boilerplate plots and garbage dialogue. Even In some of the worst anime I’ve seen, I’ve never rooted so hard against all the characters, as there is very little that is likable about them.
While there may be worse shows when it comes to specific aspects, Golgo’s repetitive nature for fifty episodes, Magical Shopping Arcade’s Voice Overs, Gravion’s bad story where most of the series’ attention was spent on boobs and panty shots, I can’t say I’ve disliked an anime, purely from a plot and character aspect, as I have this one. To top it off it comes across as an extremely lazy attempt to just profit off the dating sim it was tied to, without ever trying to make it an actual narrative driven show.
It’s so bad I’m actually looking forward to going back to Noir and finishing that up it’s last ten episodes.
For a video review, check out my Youtube channel. Link on my profile page.
This review will cover both the ef anime's: ef - a tale of memories and ef - a tale of memories
Winner JV Anime Award 2015: Best Intro Song (Euphoric Field)
*I’m going to start the positive part of this review with the music. Both intro songs from memories and melodies are so good. I really, really like them, Elisa made some awesome songs yet again. If I have to choose between Euphoric Field of memories and Ebullient Future of melodies I have to go for Euphoric Field, that’s such an amazing song on its own. The combination of the upbeat in the first part and the piano and violin solo that follows really pleased me. Euphoric Field was definitely one of the better if not the best opening song I heard this year.
*Next positive point was the animation. Each of the anime’s had one particular animation feature that I really liked. In melodies this was that the opening sequence changed a couple of times during the anime and it always represented the current mood at that time in the anime.
In memories I really liked the animation during the multiple monologues in the anime. When the characters would go into a monologue, which happens often, the animation would like represent their feelings. It’s something I had never seen before and I thought that it was awesome. It really helped building the psychological theme that was present in both anime’s.
*So let’s talk about that psychological theme because that’s the best way I can describe the ef anime’s: as being psychological dramas. We really go into the mind of the characters and experience their feelings, their thoughts, their turmoil. Ef went so much deeper with their characters than any other anime I’ve seen before.
And in this psychological theme also lay the foundation for the drama in ef. The fact that we can see into the character’s minds build an intens amount of drama but not like sad, tearjerking drama that we see in most drama anime’s. It’s psychological drama, that’s again the best way I can describe the drama in ef. It’s something I never experienced in anime before.
*Going further about the characters, I was amazed by the complexity of the relationships between all the characters. Especially when you get into melodies, all the characters and all the storylines of both memories and melodies start to intertwine forming this very complex and therefor intriguing network.
*Now let’s talk about the story lines. There were some of the story lines that I really liked and one I didn’t like so that one’s for the negative part. The storyline I liked the most was the one of Chihiro and Renji from memories. Their storyline was the most interesting, intriguing and sad storyline of the four caused by the drama that emerged from Chihiro’s illness and the way Renji tries to deal with that.
That turmoil that we see Chihiro go through, also again with those monologues, created an strong bond between me and Chihiro. Also I loved the end of their storyline, although it being a bit predictable. I still loved the way they eventually found a way to be together.
*Which brings me seamlessly to the romance and I will specify more on the romance between Chihiro and Renji. I loved them as a couple, they just fit together. The way how they overcome the struggles in their relationship made me ship their relationship.
Because they really want to be together but Chihiro’s illness prevents this and it put their relationship under immense pressure. Even to the point that one of the two thinks that the relationship is bothersome to the other. But the way that they keep fighting for their relationship was very heartwarming to see and me rout even more for them as a couple.
And then something special I have to mention about the romance in memories. In memories the 2 couples go further than a couple normally goes in these kind of anime's. But it didn't bother me at all, I found that the sex scenes or the after sex scenes I should call it were done in a very mature and respectful manner, something that made Ef stand out even more.
*So before I said that there was one storyline I didn't like and that was the one of Mizuki and Shuichi in melodies. First of all, I didn't rout for their relationship. I found that there was to much difference between them, in age in particular. I never really shipped their relationship also maybe because I found the Yuu-Yuuko storyline a lot more interesting.
*But apart from me not shipping their relationship, the biggest bother was the end of their storyline. That was so cliché, I saw it coming from miles away that they would go for the miracle ending. I was hoping they wouldn't but unfortunately the writers took the easy way out here. Their story would have been a lot more satisfying if they didn't went for the miracle ending but I realize that there aren't a lot of anime's that dare to take the risk of creating such a non happy ending.
*Then the other storyline between Yuu and Yuuko, that was a much better storyline but I had a question after the end. Does Yuu realize who Mizuki is at the end of melodies? Logic says that he does, it would be pretty weird if he didn't realize who she was. But still, to me it wasn't really clear, I was left in the middle there.
*And a last negative point was that I still don't fully understand the reason why Yuuko's still present. I understand that she helps the current characters and that she's like waiting for Yuu. By the way, in memories Yuuko doesn't make any sense, you have to watch melodies in order to understand why she's in these anime’s. But after melodies I still don't completely understand the why, what her reason is to still be present.
So as a conclusion ef was quite the ride, going much deeper than most of its colleagues in the romance genre. I enjoyed memories a bit more than melodies and that why I’m going to rate ef-a tale of memories at 4 stars and ef- a tale of melodies at 3,5 stars. If you like romance anime's with loads of dept, definitely check these two out.
it was really good, but the sexual scences were waaay too much. i like the bacground story but after a while it kinda of dragged