Story: For a host of reasons, I should have liked AnoHana. After all, the series has glimpses of interesting drama and romance, paralleled by a tragic story of loss, grieving, and unhealed wounds. Follow my reviews on here long enough, and you’ll see these genres are almost slam-dunks for a “good” evaluation from me, even if they have a lot of flaws.
Oddly, though, AnoHana decided to open with a weird scene – namely, it starts with an overbearing and loud Menma rubbing her rear end all over an adolescent boy’s crotch in some weird attempt at innocent ecchi humor. For trying to tackle thematically heavy topics, this was a strange and unsuccessful hook, opening the show to me on a sour note. More, I quickly started to hate Menma’s character within about the first five minutes, as she’s so obnoxiously loud and her dialogue involves a lot of repetition to the point of annoyance. While a series like Golden Time starts you out raw with some characters and uses this as an opportunity for growth, however, AnoHana fails to clear even its first hurdle, leaving you with a cast of characters who feel very much the same from start to finish. Menma, along with her five left-behind companions, are as static in the final episode as they are in the first – admittedly, her dialogue gets a bit subdued by the end, but that’s about it.
The base problem with AnoHana is that it relies entirely on melodrama to try to advance its story. Its central premise attempts to explore the concept of emotions being trapped at someone’s death and creating wounds that often heal imperfectly with time; yet, this seems to be in the form of a complicated five-way love-triangle free-for-all among prepubescent ten year olds. Indeed, it even tries to play on the concept of “the boys think the girls are icky” to motivate much of its drama, which makes little sense given how grievously Menma’s death apparently has affected the group. The premise could have been handled far more maturely, starting with a high-school tragedy as the cast leads into young adulthood (in the vein of Kimi ga Nozomu Eien); as it was told, however, it’s just not believable.
Come its final episodes, the conclusion was predictable and expected, and the only loose end that’s attempted to be tied up is that of Poppo – the only one in the group of six kids not involved in the romantic subplots. To put the icing on the cake, when his motivations for dealing with Menma were revealed, I found them the most compelling out of all the other characters. His story seemed to have the most human and empathic undercurrent to the grander plot, and was thrown in as a 60 second side-plot in an attempt to give his character some sort of closure.
All in all, AnoHana’s story is just awkward. It struggles to be both comedic and dramatic at the same time, and places Menma on a strange pedestal around which all the other characters must orbit. Realistically, human beings deal with loss and grieving in highly complex ways, and at times the show displays that it understands this. Yet, the melodrama forces forward a bulldozing simplicity into the story that seems to sweep away all this higher potential. Ultimately, despite wanting something more, I was left unsatisfied and unimpressed.
Animation:
In the brief time spent compiling this review, many of AnoHana’s finer points all seem to have vanished. The animators went out of their way to try do the weird display of some-girls-having-makeup-while-others-do-not, which created a lot of awkward visuals where the characters on screen did not tend to blend well together. There are also several high-quality frames that were animated beautifully, such as the suspension bridge which acts a focal point for much of the drama, but these are reused heavily. Though not bad in and of itself, the rest of the show often seems very plain in comparison – especially when it comes to secondary characters. While not bad per se, it just feels off at times and a bit tacky.
Sound:
The musical score in AnoHana is functional. Nothing really stood out or impressed me in any particular manner, though the dramatic scenes had some decent pieces playing in them. Still, like the rest of the show, it felt like the score was a half-miss for all but the last episode. Perhaps it was the written juxtaposition of comedy and drama that made it hard for the composer to pin down a style, but the series never really developed a good musical feel to synchronize its intended emotional development from start to finish.
Voice acting was also a mixed bag. Menma’s seiyuu grated on me early and often, largely because her child-like dialogue just did not fit well with themes attempting to be discussed. In general, it felt like the talent was solid but the writing was poor, which held back a lot of the potential. The exchange in the final episode between Anjou and Tsurumi was a great example of how good the actors could perform if given the right scenes, but in general the voicework seemed general and average.
Characters:
The core of the story focuses on six childhood friends who lose one of their group, a young girl named Menma, to a tragic accident that causes the group to all go their separate ways. The ways each character handles the loss causes many to start to dislike one another, and particularly impacts the extroverted “leader” of the gang, Jinta, to spiral into a wave of depression that leaves him an awkward shut-in as he advances into his teenage years. When Menma suddenly appears in front of him, he starts to try to grab the others and lay to rest everyone’s grief.
The other characters all have their own issues with Menma’s death, expectedly, and not all have to do the girl herself. Jinta, for example, also struggles with the loss of his mother, and Anjou struggles to find legitimate friendships to replace those she has lost. Each individual conflict has the potential to be interesting and impactful, and sometimes the show does manage to tap into them very well and explore the characters in a thorough and human way. Anjou and Poppo, in particular, were quite well done.
For the most part, though, most of the issues the cast faces seem very superficial and forced. Unfortunately, the particular subplot I would like to rail on the most would spoil several of the first few episodes, and the opening to the show is by far the series’ strongest run. At the crux of the problem, the series just fundamentally struggles to transition 10-year-olds into believable teenagers, and Menma’s tragic death fails to really have strong impact given how central of an active role she plays in the events that transpire.
Overall:
Disappointment, disappointment, disappointment. I wanted to like AnoHana, but its combination of poor writing and tacky melodrama just strip away what could have been an emotional and gripping story. The final episode will likely get a drop of water in your eyes, but for the themes involved and conflict between the characters being pushed, the show should have had no problem at least getting a couple tears. All in all, AnoHana ends up a very average show plagued with the conventional “unused potential” label, and while I would recommend to those who like drama and romance generally, all others should give this title a pass.